Player ratings

[Kinky Gerbil]

Just got back

Henderson - 10 Fantastic best keeping display if seen for a long time 5 fantastic saves, punched well, caught well - set up goal with throw out

Hart 7 - only downside gave lewis bit to much space

butters 7 - did well in air


mCSHANE 8 - First time ive seen him -MCGHEE SIGN HIM NOW

Reid 7 - solid

Hammond - 8 so much better than charlie

Chippy - 7 works well with hammond

Carole - 8 Set up 1 and scored one through Harding legs

Jarrett - 7 uns like a chicken, looked good going forward - still cant tackle
tho

Robinson - 7 ranwell passed well -tired at end

Knight 9 - set up 2 scored one

oatway - 6 not on long enough

Richards - 6 did he really have to dive in for the foul in last min?


Mcghee -6 should he have change things earlier? Should he have subbed a playher off when they had an attacking free kick?

 

[Schrödinger's Toad]

Henderson 9

Reid 8
Butters 7
McShane 8
Hart 7

Jarrett 7
Hammond 8
Carpenter 7
Carole 9

Knight 9
Robinson 8

 

[Silent Bob]

Henderson 9 - Improving with every game it seems. I didn't rate him to begin with but have been won over by improved displays.

Reid 7- Didn't put a foot wrong, reliable.
Butters 7- Dominated Hulse in the air.
McShane 8 - CLASS.
Hart 7- Nothing majorly wrong with him as a right back.

Jarrett 7- looked good again
Hammond 7- did well, proabbly should have scored
Carpenter 7- good game
Carole 9- Excellent. This guy is class, I have no idea why he didn't do too well at West Ham and had a trial at Southampton but was turned down. Their loss is our gain though.

Knight 9- Great. Looking much better this season especially with this attacking line up. Apparently wants to claim the OG as a goal for him.
Robinson 8- Lively again

 

[Kinky Gerbil]

Henderson 9 - Improving with every game it seems. I didn't rate him to begin with but have been won over by improved displays.

Reid 7- Didn't put a foot wrong, reliable.
Butters 7- Dominated Hulse in the air.
McShane 8 - CLASS.
Hart 7- Nothing majorly wrong with him as a right back.

Jarrett 7- looked good again
Hammond 7- did well, proabbly should have scored
Carpenter 7- good game
Carole 9- Excellent. This guy is class, I have no idea why he didn't do too well at West Ham and had a trial at Southampton but was turned down. Their loss is our gain though.

Knight 9- Great. Looking much better this season especially with this attacking line up. Apparently wants to claim the OG as a goal for him.
Robinson 8- Lively again

To be fair Virgo go the one at Withers last year!

 

[Silent Bob]

Yep, if he gets it he'll be almost at his total for last season.

 

[Turkey]

Henderson 8

Reid 7
Butters 7
McShane 7
Hart 7

Jarrett 7
Hammond 8
Carpenter 7
Carole 8

Knight 8
Robinson 8

 

[Roger Mellie]

Henderson 9 - Improving with every game it seems. I didn't rate him to begin with but have been won over by improved displays.

Reid 7- Didn't put a foot wrong, reliable.
Butters 7- Dominated Hulse in the air.
McShane 8 - CLASS.
Hart 7- Nothing majorly wrong with him as a right back.

Jarrett 7- looked good again
Hammond 7- did well, proabbly should have scored
Carpenter 7- good game
Carole 9- Excellent. This guy is class, I have no idea why he didn't do too well at West Ham and had a trial at Southampton but was turned down. Their loss is our gain though.

Knight 9- Great. Looking much better this season especially with this attacking line up. Apparently wants to claim the OG as a goal for him.
Robinson 8- Lively again

Errr if butters was so dominate how come Hulse had half a dozen chances he should have put away?? Our centre backs looked in trouble whenever the ball was put in the air. Apart from that I generally agree with your ratings

 

[king Wombat]

Henderson - 7. Couple of good saves, but a couple of fumbles. Thought he should have prevented the last goal.
Hart - 7 looks quite good at right back
Reid - 7 Looks quite good at left back!
Mcshane - 8 Great but was left exposed by Butters
Butters - 6 Leeds strikers gave him a torrid time today. should have done better for the second leeds goal.
Carole - 9 My MOM scared the shit out of the leeds defence
Hammond - 7 Solid
Carpenter - 7 Ditto
Jarret - 8 Couple of great runs
Knight - 8 all over the place, looks to have a great partnership with carole
Robinson - 6.5 Bottled quite a few tackles and didn't really look great on the left wing when Jarrett came off.


Referee 1 Bloody awful.

 

[Kinky Gerbil]

Henderson - 7. Couple of good saves, but a couple of fumbles. Thought he should have prevented the last goal.
Hart - 7 looks quite good at right back
Reid - 7 Looks quite good at left back!
Mcshane - 8 Great but was left exposed by Butters
Butters - 6 Leeds strikers gave him a torrid time today. should have done better for the second leeds goal.
Carole - 9 My MOM scared the shit out of the leeds defence
Hammond - 7 Solid
Carpenter - 7 Ditto
Jarret - 8 Couple of great runs
Knight - 8 all over the place, looks to have a great partnership with carole
Robinson - 6.5 Bottled quite a few tackles and didn't really look great on the left wing when Jarrett came off.


Referee 1 Bloody awful.

when did henderson thumble? he was unlucky with last goal good save

 

[king Wombat]

Second half he fumbled a couple of times. Thought he could have done better with the last goal.

 

[Kinky Gerbil]

Second half he fumbled a couple of times. Thought he could have done better with the last goal.

Did he - must have missed that he punched it a couple of times - but they went well clear of danger and into touch

 

[London Irish]

Henderson 8 Kept us in the game in the first 10mins when Leeds could have gone two or three up

Reid 7 Calm work
Butters 6 Solid, but a fast and open game like this is not exactly made for him!
McShane 8 Tackles and wins ball like a man possessed
Hart 7 Will keep Dodd out if he plays this diligently

Jarrett 6 OK-ish game but still the weak link at times in terms of end product.
Hammond 7 Strong performance, shame about the shocking miss!
Carpenter 7 Mr consistency, directed our play effectively
Carole 9 Rightwing genius - and it takes a lot for me to pair those two words.

Knight 8 Marvellous trickery - his best game for a while
Robinson 6 Solid work but will have better games than this

Kazim-Richards 7 Good substitution by McGhee, lifted us on to the third goal when we looked to be running out of steam.

Oatway Just had a few minutes

 

[Yorkie]

Henderson 8

Reid 8
Butters 7
McShane 8
Hart 7

Jarrett 7
Hammond 8
Carpenter 7
Carole 9

Knight 9
Robinson 8

 

[Withdean Wanderer]

Henderson 8 - kept us in it

Reid 7 - a fairly quiet game, but don't rememeber him doing anything wrong.
Butters 7 - solid
McShane 8 - fantastic
Hart 7 - not the greatest of performances, but kept them out in the 2nd half in particular

Jarrett 7 - good couple of runs
Hammond 7 - always looking for the ball in the middle of the park
Carpenter 7 - ditto Hammond
Carole 9 - superb, Harding couldn't get near him

Knight 9 - awesome
Robinson 8 - just gets a 8 simply for THAT tackle on Harding..

Well played all round!

 

[Trigger]

Oatway Just had a few minutes

10?

 

[e77]

Henderson 8

Reid 7
Butters 6
McShane 7
Hart 6

Jarrett 7
Hammond 7
Carpenter 7
Carole 9

Knight 9
Robinson 7

 

[kevinsmith]

Henderson 8

Reid 8
Butters 7
McShane 8
Hart 7

Jarrett 7
Hammond 8
Carpenter 7
Carole 9

Knight 9
Robinson 8

Your marks are spot on as far as I'm concerned Yorkie

 

[Scotty Mac]

henderson 8
hart 7
butters 6
mcshane 7
reid 6
carole 8
carpenter 7
hammond 7
jarrett 6
robinson 7
knight 8.5

kazim richards 5
oatway 6

 

[Shropshire Seagull]

when did henderson fumble? he was unlucky with last goal good save

2nd half, one of their players ran right through us but his last touch was too strong - Henderson came out to smother but it bounced off him for a corner - bit clumsy, but don't let this overshadow the "blinder" he played ....

And he made our first goal with that throw out to Carole that was well into the Leeds half ....

I'd give him a nine

 

[Kinky Gerbil]

2nd half, one of their players ran right through us but his last touch was too strong - Henderson came out to smother but it bounced off him for a corner - bit clumsy, but don't let this overshadow the "blinder" he played ....

And he made our first goal with that throw out to Carole that was well into the Leeds half ....

I'd give him a nine

True - Yes now wait for people to say how Kuipers kicking is better than henderson.....