player evaluations

[kalinx]

If you were to pick the 5 most highly valuable players to us in terms of monetary value who would they be and how much do you think they are worth if we were to sell them?

Mine prob

Elphick

Murray

Lynch

Mcleod

Cox

Not sure about valuations tho!

 

[blockhseagull]

In terms of pound notes value

Murray, Elphick, Cox, Virgo and Lynch.

In value to the team

Forster, Murray, McLeod, Elphick and Whing

 

[BensGrandad]

In Transfer values:
Cox £500k +
Murray £500k+
Elphick £300k
Lynch£250K
Forster £200k (in January to a struggling championship side)

the rest of the team less than £50k.

 

[Deano's Invisible Pants]

Michel - priceless
Lynch - £750k
Murray - £600k
Elphick - £500k
Cox £300k

Can't see us getting 750k for Lynch when he's not getting in our side, although a fit and in-form Lynch could well be worth that sort of money. My guess is that if someone offered 300k for him right now we would probably take it.

 

[Tom Hark Preston Park]

Struggling to find five players who would command any kind of meaningful fee come the January transfer window. So I'll go four.

1. Murray 650K
2. Mcleod 300K
3. Elphick 250K + sell-on
4. Forster 100K

Deliberately missed out Lynch. Sadly seems not to be building on his earlier promise very much. A bit like Jake hasn't. The days of generating big cash windfalls from the youth team graduates seem to be over for now.

 

[Napper]

Elphick 500k
Murray 300k
Cox 250k
Lynch 100k
Think the rest would be less than 100k

 

[vulture]

Elphick 1,000,000
Cox 750,000
Lynch 750,000
Murrary 500,000
Livermore 250,000

 

[SICKASAGULL]

500k for Cox, are you having a laugh,we would do well to accept £5000,and throw in Robinson as a buy one, get one free.

 

[Tom Hark Preston Park]

Elphick 1,000,000
Cox 750,000
Lynch 750,000
Murrary 500,000
Livermore 250,000

Are you head-mental by any chance?

 

[1066familyman]

I'm curious why only one person so far has included Virgo. Am I missing something ? Does him coming back on a free affect any sale ?

Anyway, excluding Virgo for the time being, and Richards of course because he's only on loan :-

Murray 600 k
Elphick 300 k
Lynch 300 k
Cox 250 k
Whing 100 k

I too would want sell on clauses with our three youngsters in that list though.

 

[steward 433]

500k for Cox, are you having a laugh,we would do well to accept £5000,and throw in Robinson as a buy one, get one free.

:thud: Shows how little you know then dosen't it!!

 

[Rookie]

Elphick, Lynch and Murray would get reasonable money. Cox might fetch a few quid if he can get a bit of consistency. Forster is now too old to get much and the rest are journey men and free transfers so not going to get much there

 

[BensGrandad]

500k for Cox, are you having a laugh,we would do well to accept £5000,

That fee, £500k, was offered/turned down last season, allegedly.

 

[steward 433]

That fee, £500k,was turned down last season, allegedly.

Correct and twice from 2 different clubs i believe

 

[HseagullsH]

Lynch
Elphick
Murray
Mcleod

 

[Tom Hark Preston Park]

Correct and twice from 2 different clubs i believe

And Uncle Dick never took the money? Find that very hard to believe

 

[steward 433]

And Uncle Dick never took the money? Find that hard to believe

Cox himself wanted to stay

Like he said at the fans forum he would never sell a player who wanted to stay.

 

[Tom Hark Preston Park]

Cox himself wanted to stay

Like he said at the fans forum he would never sell a player who wanted to stay.

Fair enough explanation. Only explanation in fact.

 

[BensGrandad]

I know of 1 premiership club that approached him according to his mother and steward 433 said of another.