Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊

Peter Taylor was he so bad ?



(was)DBS

New member
Jul 24, 2003
1,472
Southwick
you love it you little minx

xx
 




Hamilton

Well-known member
NSC Patron
Jul 7, 2003
13,482
Brighton
I thought he did a good job, was honest and straight with us throughout. I've got no problems with him.
 




Where is Danny Seagull's mate when you need her?!? lol!

I would like to talk about football - even if I do call Booker Brooker and thought Taylor brought Kitson! but I do try!

I suggest you lot get yourselves down the pussycat club in hove
 


















magoo

New member
Jul 8, 2003
6,682
United Kingdom
oapdodge said:
Coppell got us relegated and just used the ground as an excuse.In the middle of the season with not much time to get a replacement easily.

Hinshelwood got us relegated!

I've said before that Taylor was a better manager than most gave him credit for. Look what happened when Hinshelwood took over the exact same players!!

I'd rather have kept Taylor than Coppel.
 






perth seagull

Well-known member
Jul 5, 2003
5,487
Coppell is a better manager than Taylor. Taylor just used Adams' team to win us the championship. Coppell like Adams, can build a team from scratch. Taylor can't, unless he has lots of cash to spend (and even then he can't do that, just look at what he did to Leicester).

That said, I bet Taylor's Hull will overtake us in the Football League.
 


Icy Gull

Back on the rollercoaster
Jul 5, 2003
72,015
perth seagull said:
Coppell is a better manager than Taylor. Taylor just used Adams' team to win us the championship. Coppell like Adams, can build a team from scratch. Taylor can't, unless he has lots of cash to spend (and even then he can't do that, just look at what he did to Leicester).

That said, I bet Taylor's Hull will overtake us in the Football League.


Apart from not spending as much money is MA doing any better at Leicester then?

Taylor, on the other hand is doing a brilliant job at Hull.
 




perth seagull

Well-known member
Jul 5, 2003
5,487
Icy Gull said:
Apart from not spending as much money is MA doing any better at Leicester then?

Taylor, on the other hand is doing a brilliant job at Hull.

I don't want to take any credit away from Taylor, but he has got a lot of money to spend at Hull, so he is effectively buying them the championship.

Adams had to work for a club in administration and had to make the best out of limited resources with no cash to spend. Yet he took them up to the Premiership in his first season. The club are still cleaning up the mess made under the Taylor regime.
 


Jul 24, 2003
2,289
Newbury, Berkshire.
Sorry, but this is Hull in the 3rd Division, not Leicester in the Premiership.

The 3rd Division ain't exactly the most skillfull football in the world. Spend some money on decent players and it's no surprise you can get out of it. But that philosophy didn't keep Leicester in the Premiership. Peter Taylor cannot be good at both using the same tactics.

If Taylor had agreed to talk to Madejski, Madejski wouldn't be talking to Coppell - this tells me that Taylor won't take risks because he doesn't rate himself up to the job of matching Readings expectations. Coppell has much better experience of working to tight financial constraints, is prepared to take risks ( can't see Taylor putting Jake Robinson into the first team squad so early, can you ? ) and is therefore a better manager for us.

Taylor is, at best, a 1st / 2nd Div manager. In no way is he a ' great ' manager, merely a competent one.

Not so bad, but would probably have got us relegated just as fast as Hinsh started to.
 








Captain Sensible

Well-known member
Jul 8, 2003
6,438
Not the real one
Adams mate. On old NSC when I was logged as The Jerk, I had a few heated debates with oapdoge over Hinshelwood and Taylor. Both of which I hate. While he may not squeeze his balls he would give them both a peck on the cheek and his phone humber.
 
Last edited:


Albion and Premier League latest from Sky Sports


Top
Link Here