How would you change it?

[Turkey]

                Roberts

El-Abd     Cullip     Virgo     Mayo

Hart     Reid     Nicolas     Jones

          Molango    Jarrett

Kuipers did nothing wrong so don't read much into that.

Butters is too slow. With him the defence have to sit deep or they'll be caught out. Harding isn't up to it.

We need Hart/Jones's expirience. Currie/Jarrett are not part of a 'team' yet. No shape at all.

We desperatly need a big striker.

 

[fatboy]

Not El-Abd. Too prone to errors. I'd play Hinshelwood there. We don't want El-Abd getting like Harding.

Jones and Hart on the wings. Jarrett hasn't convinced me yet.

I'd play JR from the start with Molango.

[size=4] [b] 
            Kuipers
Hinshelwood Cullip Butters Mayo
   Hart Hammond Nicolas Jones
        Molango Robinson
[/b][/size]

May
Jarrett
Virgo
Reid
Lee

 

[Albion Edd]

I'd agree with Turkeys team though I might put Jarrett on the left and put Robinson up front.

 

[saafend_seagull]

Roberts

El ebd Cullip Butters

Hart Jones

Reid Nicolas Jarrett

Molango Robinson

Hart can get up and down the line easily, and will track back well to defend. jonah and jarrett would link up well, and jonah also tracks back well. El ebd may not be the tallest but is strong. if not him, then maybe virgo. ~This is supposed to be 3-5-2 with hart/jones as wingbacks but i cant change it so it displays like it!

Reid could also swap for hart and currie comes in perhaps.

 

[Trigger]

Leaving out the injured players...


Kuipers/Roberts (not fussed)

Hinshelwood Cullip Virgo Jones

Hart Reid Nicolas Jarrett

Molango Robinson

 

[Easy 10]

I think what IS clear is that before you even look at the personnel, you have to get the shape of the team right - and McGhee blew that completely out of the water by playing 5 across the middle, with a left-back in central midfield.

Square pegs in round holes DO. NOT. WORK.

As Turkeys team and some of the others on this thread have shown, we DID have options to fit into a straight 4-4-2, where everyone knows their position and their role. Instead, what we had tonight was a disastrous hotchpotch of players in an unfamiliar formation, with Molango totally isolated in front of a badly misfiring midfield.

I sincerely hope tonight was just a one-off experiment by McGhee, and he brings back some sanity on Saturday - because if thats what Plymouth can do to us under those circumstances, then Coventry will absolutely rip us to shreds.

 

[Turkey]

Re: Re: How would you change it?

McGhee left Hart out on Saturday because he isn't a striker. I don't think Jarrett is either.

Neither do I. I don't see any better options personally. Jarrett/Hart/Robinson. Don't think it makes much difference.

 

[Kryten]

[b]

             Kuipers
El-Abd  Cullip  Butters  Jones
  Hart  Reid  Nicolas  Jarrett
        Molango Robinson
[/b]

subs:

Roberts (if fit)/May
Currie
Mayo/Hinshelwood
Virgo
Lee

 

[jmc]

erm, are these teams for Saturday or rest of the season, coz you seem to have missed someone out.......














..... hint:he plays up front!

 

[Kryten]

erm, are these teams for Saturday or rest of the season, coz you seem to have missed someone out.......














..... hint:he plays up front!

i thought it was just for the next game...with the available players

 

[jmc]

doesn't say that though

fairy muff...carry on

 

[Kryten]

doesn't say that though

fairy muff...carry on

in that case

[b]

               Kuipers
El-Abd  Cullip  Blackwell  Jones
  Hart  Chippy Nicolas  Jarrett
        Molango  knight 

[/b]

subs:
Roberts
Butters
Oatway
Rodger
Robinson

 

[Richy_Seagull]

                      Roberts

Virgo         Cullip         Butters            Mayo                   


Hart          Reid           Nicolas            Jarrett


                Molango     Robinson

Kuipers
Harding
Currie
Hinshelwood
Jones

 

[BensGrandad]

Doesn't the suspensions now start immediately with the next game?

if so

Roberts

El Abd
Cullip
Virgo
Butters
Mayo

Currie
Reid
Nicholas
Jarrett

Molango

With El Abd and Mayo attacking as wingbacks thus allowing Currie and Jarret to push forward to become the 2nd striker depending on which side of the park the play is

 

[trueblue]

                      Roberts

Virgo         Cullip         Butters            Mayo                   


Hart          Reid           Nicolas            Jarrett


                Molango     Robinson


Absolutely not. Robinson will hardly get a look in. If Hart's to play it ought to be up front where his strength at least may be enough of a distraction to give Molango a chance. Keep Currie in. 

Ben's Grandad's 5-4-1 looks good to me (although a case for Hinshelwood in there, with Virgo staying on the right)

 

[Turkey]

Well I've changed my mind, as always.

                  Roberts

El-Abd     Cullip    Virgo     Jones

     Hart    Nicolas    Mayo 
Currie                        Jarrett
               Molango

Hart to replace Reid as Hart can support right back.

Mayo in midfield as we need a defencive, left footed, midfielder.

Jones at left back for his pace and lack of alternatives.

 

[London Irish]

[

                        Roberts

     El-Abd     Cullip    Virgo     Mayo

      Hinshelwood    Nicolas    Reid 
Jarrett                                         Jonah
                       Molango

I would bring in El Abd for the out-of-form Virgo.

I would drop Currie, not because he hasn't a future with us, but he's wasted in a 4-5-1. With that system, you need your wide players to have the pace to support the lone attacker, both Jarrett and Jonah have that, Currie does not, too often tonight he was trapped on his wing looking for a pass that wasn't there, we need something more individually creative than that who can beat his marker. Although Jarrett is left-winger, he can also play on the right if you study your match programme tonight.

If we were on top, I would also be looking for Hinshelwood to press forward to support Molango in the manner of his excellent goal at Cambridge.

 

[goldstone]

Hart up front with Molango. He was an inspiration when he came on as striker in the home playoff game against Swindon. He holds the ball up well and, considering his height, gets up very well to high balls.
Jake did very little when he came on last night. In fact I don't think he touched the ball for the first 15 minutes!

 

[Deleted User X18H]

                Roberts

El-Abd     Cullip     Virgo     Mayo

Hart     Reid     Nicolas     Jones

          Molango    Jarrett

Kuipers did nothing wrong so don't read much into that.

Butters is too slow. With him the defence have to sit deep or they'll be caught out. Harding isn't up to it.

We need Hart/Jones's expirience. Currie/Jarrett are not part of a 'team' yet. No shape at all.

We desperatly need a big striker.

Thats almost exactly why I said on Hove B&B'S difinitive guide ..................

 

[Lammy]

Last night I would have played

                Kuipers

Virgo    Cullip     Butters   Harding

Hart     Reid     Nicolas     Jarett

          Molango    Robinson

In future I would play

                Roberts

Virgo    Cullip     Butters   Harding

Hart     Chippy     Nicolas     Jarett

          Knight       Molango