[Albion] Knocky`s card ,right or wrong

Paris

Well-known member

Jul 17, 2010

4,076

13th district

• Mar 12, 2019

• #21

Refs don't want to send players off so early in a match. Especially one as passionate as Palace v Brighton. Rare to see a red card anywhere so early in a game.

 

P

PoG

Well-known member

Oct 29, 2013

1,117

• Mar 12, 2019

• #22

Booking for both in my eyes.

 

Icy Gull

Back on the rollercoaster

Jul 5, 2003

72,015

• Mar 12, 2019

• #23

Palace player should have got the same card as Knocky. Ref got it wrong imo, they were both either guilty or not guilty.

 

grubbyhands

Well-known member

Dec 8, 2011

2,285

Godalming

• Mar 12, 2019

• #24

daveinplzen said:

I viewed it from the other way round. Thought the Palace git deliberately used his balls to try and damage Knockaerts ankle.

Click to expand...

Is the correct answer.

 

Papa Lazarou

Living in a De Zerbi wonderland

Jul 7, 2003

18,858

Worthing

• Mar 12, 2019

• #25

Agree. Should have been yellow for both.

 

LamieRobertson

Not awoke

Feb 3, 2008

46,673

SHOREHAM BY SEA

• Mar 12, 2019

• #26

Yellow......simple as that...note the Palace player holding his shin after ..wasn't bothered with his tackle at all

 

M

maglers

Active member

Apr 26, 2011

343

• Mar 12, 2019

• #27

Ref was doing them a favour by only booking Knocky. We all know what happens when we play them with only 10 men...

 

jackanada

Well-known member

Jul 19, 2011

3,157

Brighton

• Mar 12, 2019

• #28

I saw it as they both went in two footed and AK has lifted a foot back up to avoid his studs going into Milli Vanillis leg. Ok he got the plums but thats not a potential career ender.
If the ref really wanted to pull a Complete and Utter Shyster he could have given them both red and then restarted the game with the unusual sight of a contested drop ball, probably resulting in another double red as two angry players take it as an excuse to boot the other straight in the knee.

 

The Antikythera Mechanism

The oldest known computer

NSC Patron

Aug 7, 2003

7,792

• Mar 12, 2019

• #29

Milivojevic must have somehow withdrawn his clockweights into his groin, to have recovered so quickly. Either that or he’s one of those sado-masochists who like getting booted in the nads for fun.

 

Wellesley

Well-known member

Jul 24, 2013

4,973

• Mar 12, 2019

• #30

Red.

 

M

Muzzy

Well-known member

Jan 25, 2011

4,786

Lewes

• Mar 12, 2019

• #31

I thought it was 50/50 at the time. Still do after all the debates.
A typical first challenge in a local Derby.. only it isn't a derby anymore is it?

Yellow at worst for both players imo.

 

dazzer6666

Well-known member

NSC Patron

Mar 27, 2013

52,369

Burgess Hill

• Mar 12, 2019

• #32

METALMICKY said:

Nailed on red. I can't believe how many people are missing the quite deliberate secondary " pushing " action aimed directly at their players groin. Obviously, delighted that he did not go off. On Sky analysis Dermot Gallagher suggests not sending him off was the correct decision and that it should have been two yellows as both went in with studs up. Again this overlooks Knocky's secondary action.

Click to expand...

Absolutely this. The secondary push was deliberate and obvious......



.....[emoji23][emoji23][emoji23][emoji23][emoji23]

 

B

Bodian

Well-known member

May 3, 2012

11,801

Cumbria

• Mar 12, 2019

• #33

The Antikythera Mechanism said:

Milivojevic must have somehow withdrawn his clockweights into his groin, to have recovered so quickly. Either that or he’s one of those sado-masochists who like getting booted in the nads for fun.

Click to expand...

Even more oddly, it was his shin (which received no contact) that he was holding. Makes me think Knocky didn't put much force on his tackle after all.