Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊

[Football] Train chaos



Beach Hut

Brighton Bhuna Boy
Jul 5, 2003
71,974
Living In a Box
They cut the services during Covid and not bought full services back. So (from Worthing) two trains an hour of three carriages. You can go to Hove on the London, but connecting service no longer runs.

Really ?

Given I live in Shoreham and use trains regularly I would never have known that
 






A1X

Well-known member
NSC Patron
Sep 1, 2017
17,869
Deepest, darkest Sussex
Genuine question here though, where do Southern get the carriages from? And how do they fit them on a platform that only has room for 8?

I don't think Southern can get anymore trains on tbh, Network Rail need to upgrade the infrastructure.

I can’t speak for last night but on Saturday, at a guess, maybe out of the sidings at Brighton where there were loads just sitting around?
 


Wozza

Shite Supporter
Jul 6, 2003
23,630
Online
I arrived at Brighton station this evening at around 17.45, and joined a not very large queue ("excellent", I thought). I was adjacent to those toilets at the coffee shop, so quite near those doors before you get onto the platform. And then we waited, and waited...

It took until 18.20 till I was on a train. And then, the train didn't leave the station till 18.40. So I spent nearly an hour from entering the station, to departing it. Christ knows what the queues were like behind me. I'm sure there's a very good reason for this clusterf*ck of a "service", but whats the point.

I arrived at Brighton at 18.05, just missed getting on the train you're referring to (was due to leave at 18.38), and got on next one - on platform 5 - which left at 18.30.

:lolol: :lolol: :lolol:
 


Easy 10

Brain dead MUG SHEEP
Jul 5, 2003
61,772
Location Location
I arrived at Brighton at 18.05, just missed getting on the train you're referring to (was due to leave at 18.38), and got on next one - on platform 5 - which left at 18.30.

:lolol: :lolol: :lolol:

You're not helping :angry:
 




beorhthelm

A. Virgo, Football Genius
Jul 21, 2003
35,313
seems with the reduced service post covid, club need to front up some cost for either train specials or buses.
 


Beach Hut

Brighton Bhuna Boy
Jul 5, 2003
71,974
Living In a Box
seems with the reduced service post covid, club need to front up some cost for either train specials or buses.

The club that lost a fortune last season…….

And may lose another fortune in the shortly to be released accounts (caveat, selling a player for £50m might have helped plug the gap)
 


LamieRobertson

Not awoke
Feb 3, 2008
46,745
SHOREHAM BY SEA
The club that lost a fortune last season…….

And may lose another fortune in the shortly to be released accounts (caveat, selling a player for £50m might have helped plug the gap)
….ye and what about a new striker and judging by various threads another ten players at least :whistle:
 






studio150

Well-known member
Jul 30, 2011
29,632
On the Border
I commuted to London for 25 years....doubt there's an excuse I haven't heard [emoji23]

And the excuse usually changed station by station on the commute.
Not forgetting that your train cancellation was usually announced after a connecting service you could have got had just left the station.
 


pure_white

Well-known member
Dec 8, 2021
1,216
There have never been extra trains mid-week since the Amex opened
I know BUT last night I looked on the National rail timetable and live updates and could see NO extra trains and the amount of ppl about seemed to back that up as does the chaos many have endured on this thread.
 




East London Exile

Active member
Jan 13, 2013
97
London
I arrived at Lewes at 18:25 on the Victoria service and was lucky enough to make it over to the Falmer platform before they closed it off and started the queue. Whist waiting for the delayed totally inadequate 3 car train to Falmer I overheard the platform supervisors talking. They tried to get the Eastbourne to Victoria service diverted via Brighton to help clear the queue. That didn’t happen as the driver was not familiar with the line via Falmer - something they couldn’t really believe!
 


Weststander

Well-known member
NSC Patron
Aug 25, 2011
64,057
Withdean area
I arrived at Lewes at 18:25 on the Victoria service and was lucky enough to make it over to the Falmer platform before they closed it off and started the queue. Whist waiting for the delayed totally inadequate 3 car train to Falmer I overheard the platform supervisors talking. They tried to get the Eastbourne to Victoria service diverted via Brighton to help clear the queue. That didn’t happen as the driver was not familiar with the line via Falmer - something they couldn’t really believe!

Work To Rule.

Something’s never change.
 


mikeyjh

Well-known member
Dec 17, 2008
4,490
Llanymawddwy
Pre-pandemic there were 6 trains per hour between Brighton and Lewes all day Monday to Saturday and the infrastructure could cope fine with that. They have cut 50% of services, so we are down to 3 trains an hour, which is effectively a Sunday service even though passenger numbers are up to approx 70% of immediate pre-Covid levels.

It's a similarly dismal story on the West Coastway.

I saw a 6 car train in the siding at Hove yesterday on my way to the ground, and lots of unused Gatwick Express stock in the sidings at Brighton (which are cleared to operate on the Coastway routes). They have the stock to lengthen all services on the East Coastway, but are not doing so. Presumably this to avoid incurring higher track access charges and/or they don't have the staff available to get them into position. The policy seems to be do the absolute minimum they can get away with in order to keep costs down, even if it means extreme overcrowding and long waits.

I got the 17:16 from Hove to Brighton last night. Much earlier than I wanted to go. But the next train was not until 17:47 and I knew this would be so packed I might not be able to board. As it was the 17:16 was rammed too (4 car), but I manage to squeeze on. On arrival at Brighton it took ages to clear the platform due to so many leaving the train mixed with perhaps 200 already waiting to board the train we arrived in. Southern really need to consider reinstating more services.

I could be wrong, but I think all service increases now have to be cleared by the treasury who are desperate to keep a lid on the huge costs of supporting the industry through the pandemic. So don't expect any services to be reinstated soon. We could be looking at a feeble Coastway timetable for some time even if passenger numbers recover more.

Not to be seen to be defending Southern BUT this is an inevitable impact of the way are railways are set up. Effectively, their revenue is guaranteed and, to an extent, limited so they will always be looking to cut costs wherever possible. Railways are a public service and should be treated as such. Unfortunately the last PM candidate to suggest nationalising the railways was seen as a lunatic by many of the public.
 




Herr Tubthumper

Well-known member
NSC Patron
Jul 11, 2003
59,604
The Fatherland
I arrived at Lewes at 18:25 on the Victoria service and was lucky enough to make it over to the Falmer platform before they closed it off and started the queue. Whist waiting for the delayed totally inadequate 3 car train to Falmer I overheard the platform supervisors talking. They tried to get the Eastbourne to Victoria service diverted via Brighton to help clear the queue. That didn’t happen as the driver was not familiar with the line via Falmer - something they couldn’t really believe!

Familiar with the line? They’re reasonably straight and go from where you are to where you want to be….it’s quite easy.
 


jackalbion

Well-known member
Aug 30, 2011
4,044
Pre-pandemic there were 6 trains per hour between Brighton and Lewes all day Monday to Saturday and the infrastructure could cope fine with that. They have cut 50% of services, so we are down to 3 trains an hour, which is effectively a Sunday service even though passenger numbers are up to approx 70% of immediate pre-Covid levels.

It's a similarly dismal story on the West Coastway.

I saw a 6 car train in the siding at Hove yesterday on my way to the ground, and lots of unused Gatwick Express stock in the sidings at Brighton (which are cleared to operate on the Coastway routes). They have the stock to lengthen all services on the East Coastway, but are not doing so. Presumably this to avoid incurring higher track access charges and/or they don't have the staff available to get them into position. The policy seems to be do the absolute minimum they can get away with in order to keep costs down, even if it means extreme overcrowding and long waits.

I got the 17:16 from Hove to Brighton last night. Much earlier than I wanted to go. But the next train was not until 17:47 and I knew this would be so packed I might not be able to board. As it was the 17:16 was rammed too (4 car), but I manage to squeeze on. On arrival at Brighton it took ages to clear the platform due to so many leaving the train mixed with perhaps 200 already waiting to board the train we arrived in. Southern really need to consider reinstating more services.

I could be wrong, but I think all service increases now have to be cleared by the treasury who are desperate to keep a lid on the huge costs of supporting the industry through the pandemic. So don't expect any services to be reinstated soon. We could be looking at a feeble Coastway timetable for some time even if passenger numbers recover more.

That 12 Car Class 455 that is in Hove Yard, I believe is for scrap and can't work on the coastway anyway. The Coastway services aren't very good in my mind (especially from Portslade where I live). I believe you are right about the treasury, presumably they don't always use the Gat Ex trains as only some drivers can use them :shrug: .
 


Uter

Well-known member
Aug 5, 2008
1,474
The land of chocolate
That 12 Car Class 455 that is in Hove Yard, I believe is for scrap and can't work on the coastway anyway. The Coastway services aren't very good in my mind (especially from Portslade where I live). I believe you are right about the treasury, presumably they don't always use the Gat Ex trains as only some drivers can use them :shrug: .

The train I saw in Hove sidings was two 3 car 313 units coupled together which clearly can work the Coastway lines. So when I heard that single 3 car units were working the East Coastway it was puzzling and frustrating given they seemingly had idle stock at Hove that could have been used to strengthen these services.

I read today that Southern are behind with driver training due to Covid, so that could be an explanation for the general problems we see today.
 


Uter

Well-known member
Aug 5, 2008
1,474
The land of chocolate
I arrived at Lewes at 18:25 on the Victoria service and was lucky enough to make it over to the Falmer platform before they closed it off and started the queue. Whist waiting for the delayed totally inadequate 3 car train to Falmer I overheard the platform supervisors talking. They tried to get the Eastbourne to Victoria service diverted via Brighton to help clear the queue. That didn’t happen as the driver was not familiar with the line via Falmer - something they couldn’t really believe!

Drivers have to be trained on and then sign for routes before they are able to drive any services over them, so it's certainly possible in theory that a driver could have signed for Victoria to Eastbourne, but not Brighton to Lewes.

I am sure there must be some drivers on here who could expand on this.
 




jackalbion

Well-known member
Aug 30, 2011
4,044
The train I saw in Hove sidings was two 3 car 313 units coupled together which clearly can work the Coastway lines. So when I heard that single 3 car units were working the East Coastway it was puzzling and frustrating given they seemingly had idle stock at Hove that could have been used to strengthen these services.

I read today that Southern are behind with driver training due to Covid, so that could be an explanation for the general problems we see today.

Oh I didn't see the 313s on Wednesday, but wouldn't be surprised, I know they can't get the 313s as six car on seafords as they can't stop at Moulescoomb and London Road due to Selective Door Opening, could have been a reason. Didn't understand why we were down to three an our on Wednesday.
 


chaileyjem

#BarberIn
NSC Patron
Jun 27, 2012
13,911
Agree but trouble is questions never include asking for opinions on Transport, Sharing scheme,Ticket prices etc. Just want to know if we liked the pie and if stewards were nice etc

If you mean the Premier League survey. Then it does have questions about travelling to matches and transport. And the club field questions about transport all the time in forums, and all the other ways they get feedback from fans and will step in multiple times when Southern can't provide a suitable service and fund at great cost things like replacement coach services, expanded park and rides and so on.. Albion of course don't run the railways but the idea that they've washed their hands of it , or somehow don't think it impacts on ticket sales, attendance and yes, the overall match day experience is wide of the mark.
See the survey from 2020. https://www.brightonandhovealbion.com/news/1627538/albion-rank-third-in-premier-league-fan-survey
 


Albion and Premier League latest from Sky Sports


Top
Link Here