POSKETT AT THE VALLEY
Well-known member
Complete and utter garbage compared to what it used to be.
Is Noel Fielding meant to be a comedian
?
Is Noel Fielding meant to be a comedian
?
Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊
[Music] Never mind the buzzcocks
- Thread starter POSKETT AT THE VALLEY
- Start date
Postman Pat
Well-known member
Complete and utter garbage compared to what it used to be.
Is Noel Fielding meant to be a comedian
Better than it was at the end, Simon Amstell was a complete cock and was just there to ridicule the guests. Not as good as the original, but prefer this incarnation than when it was pulled.
Daisy annoys me. Wish they had brought phil Jupiter back. It used to be a general music quiz, and the line up round especially was always funny as it was some random saxophone player from a 70s 1 hit wonder. Now its 'spot 3 members of steps'. Not the same. It's alright, but not a patch on the original.
Fignon's Ponytail
Well-known member
I dont mind the new series - but Daisy REALLY annoys me with that screechy laugh...especially when nothing funny has happened. Shes not funny herself, & seems to be there to just shout a lot.
Wonder if her brother being a writer on Buzzcocks has anything to do with her getting the gig - or the fact shes also on Taskmaster with Greg Davies?
Cynical...moi?
Wonder if her brother being a writer on Buzzcocks has anything to do with her getting the gig - or the fact shes also on Taskmaster with Greg Davies?
Cynical...moi?
Wrong-Direction
Well-known member
- Mar 10, 2013
- 13,416
I don't know what Noel is but it certainly isn't funny.
Sent from my SM-A600FN using Tapatalk
Sent from my SM-A600FN using Tapatalk
She did one series like many people have but they might have thought she was entertaining on Taskmaster so she will be on this but she's not the same person on this. She's obviously had a couple of drinks before filming and maybe even other performance enhancing medication.
Joey Jo Jo Jr. Shabadoo
Waxing chumps like candles since ‘75
- Oct 4, 2003
- 11,055
It’s ok. Not as good as the original series when Mark Lamar hosted it, but miles better than Simon Amstels version. Greg Davies is doing most of the heavy lifting though when it comes to actually being funny.
Never really watched the earlier incarnation, though occasionally saw the odd bit and found it quite sharp and funny at times.
Tried the new version out of curiosity, and gave up after 20 minutes or so. Painful going, with the 'celebs' obviously being pre-fed lines to say, and a format that seemed to be straining so hard it was excruciating – didn't feel naturally funny at all. After a while, it was just boring, tbh.
And while This Country is superb, Daisy May Cooper doesn't feel a good fit here.
Tried the new version out of curiosity, and gave up after 20 minutes or so. Painful going, with the 'celebs' obviously being pre-fed lines to say, and a format that seemed to be straining so hard it was excruciating – didn't feel naturally funny at all. After a while, it was just boring, tbh.
And while This Country is superb, Daisy May Cooper doesn't feel a good fit here.
I really enjoyed it in the Lamarr era but dropped out early when I went overseas. Never saw the Amstell years. Thought I’d watch the reboot out of curiosity.
It’s all personal taste but I found it dreadful. The pacing felt way off and the canned laughter was way out of proportion with the “jokes”. The whole thing felt just… wrong. Couldn’t get past 15 minutes.
It’s all personal taste but I found it dreadful. The pacing felt way off and the canned laughter was way out of proportion with the “jokes”. The whole thing felt just… wrong. Couldn’t get past 15 minutes.
Worthing exile
New member
- May 12, 2009
- 1,219
Complete and utter garbage compared to what it used to be.
Is Noel Fielding meant to be a comedian
No he isn't. He is just as bad on Bake Off. He made a joke this week about talking through his ar5e which just about summed him up.
What ever happened to Mark Lamar?
Amstell was an irritant, as shame as it had been a really good show beforehand
haven't seen the new one yet . . .
Amstell was an irritant, as shame as it had been a really good show beforehand
haven't seen the new one yet . . .
Nathan
Well-known member
- Jan 8, 2010
- 3,754
Only seen the first one of this series and thought it was poor, haven't been keen to watch anymore. But will give it one more go and see. It tries to be a music quiz and a comedy panel show, and it is neither. Not enough music questions for a music quiz and not enough funny jokes for a comedy.
You can’t go to the same party twice.
Latest news on Mark Lamarr:
"Lamarr presented a music show for British Airways on-board listeners as part of their in-flight entertainment. In this show he presented a mix of rock and roll, blues, reggae, soul and R&B".
Is this the programme where five old people lined up and the teams had to guess which one used to be the bass player in Men Without Hats, and Lamarr would say "Man without Hat; Man without teeth; Man without a clue; Man with the golden bum; Half Man Half biscuit" ?
I rather liked it but I'm with [MENTION=33848]The Clamp[/MENTION].
Anstell I watched once - he was an annoying prick who knew nothing about anything and didn't seem to care, or indeed let that stop him gobbing off.
Actually, I suspect he may be one of the NSC posters I have on ignore
"Lamarr presented a music show for British Airways on-board listeners as part of their in-flight entertainment. In this show he presented a mix of rock and roll, blues, reggae, soul and R&B".
Is this the programme where five old people lined up and the teams had to guess which one used to be the bass player in Men Without Hats, and Lamarr would say "Man without Hat; Man without teeth; Man without a clue; Man with the golden bum; Half Man Half biscuit" ?
I rather liked it but I'm with [MENTION=33848]The Clamp[/MENTION].
Anstell I watched once - he was an annoying prick who knew nothing about anything and didn't seem to care, or indeed let that stop him gobbing off.
Actually, I suspect he may be one of the NSC posters I have on ignore