[Albion] The Athletic - Brighton content

poidy · Oct 22, 2020

What’s the verdict from those on NSC that subscribe to the Athletic?

I’ve had it a year now and I’ll be honest I’ve been incredibly disappointed with the Brighton content.

Nothing personal to the journalist in question but I just find the content lacks substance and the writing style does little to draw you in.

I’ve read some brilliant long reads over the last 12 months which have been original, well researched and wouldn’t be found on any other platform.

The articles I’ve seen on Brighton though have lacked that depth and offer nothing different to what you can find within the Argus.

Shame, as there’s so much scope for creative license which isn’t being exploited at the moment.

What’s the verdict from other NSC’ers?

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Brian Fantana · Oct 22, 2020

Totally agree. The Brighton stuff has in general been a massive disappointment.

Dorset Seagull · Oct 22, 2020

Absolutely agree 100%. Some brilliant creative football content but sadly the Albion stuff is generally worse than you find on here

Questions · Oct 22, 2020

Brian Fantana said:
Totally agree. The Brighton stuff has in general been a massive disappointment.

Let’s get back to the top 6 now please.

Chinman3000 · Oct 22, 2020

Took up the £1 a month offer and it wasn't worth that.

dazzer6666 · Oct 22, 2020

poidy said:
What’s the verdict from those on NSC that subscribe to the Athletic?

I’ve had it a year now and I’ll be honest I’ve been incredibly disappointed with the Brighton content.

Nothing personal to the journalist in question but I just find the content lacks substance and the writing style does little to draw you in.

I’ve read some brilliant long reads over the last 12 months which have been original, well researched and wouldn’t be found on any other platform.

The articles I’ve seen on Brighton though have lacked that depth and offer nothing different to what you can find within the Argus.

Shame, as there’s so much scope for creative license which isn’t being exploited at the moment.

What’s the verdict from other NSC’ers?

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Yep, crap. Won’t be renewing

AZ Gull · Oct 22, 2020

I can't disagree with the OP. But then - I've heard Andy Naylor featured on a few podcasts over the last 12 months or so, and he comes across as...well, dull. If he doesn't have anything interesting to say in person, it isn't a surprise that he doesn't have much interesting to say on paper. It is unfortunate that our correspondent isn't one of our other Albion-supporting journalists, who have much more personality.

I've renewed my subscription though (at an even cheaper rate than the first time) because some of the other writing has been excellent, and I would struggle to find it elsewhere.

um bongo molongo · Oct 22, 2020

I cancelled my free trial before it was even up. Overall I find most football writing dull to be honest. Michael Atherton on cricket however is worth a Times subscription on his own.

mr sheen · Oct 22, 2020

I have read some great articles in the athletic, but sadly none of them have been about the albion

AZ Gull · Oct 22, 2020

To be fair, I should add that at least he has now discovered that we have an U-23 and U-18 squad, with a few articles on the promising youngsters that are coming through the system.

Bozza · Oct 22, 2020

AZ Gull said:
To be fair, I should add that at least he has now discovered that we have an U-23 and U-18 squad, with a few articles on the promising youngsters that are coming through the system.

Are you credited with an assist?

Super Steve Earle · Oct 23, 2020

I'm going against the grain here. I've had my subscription for about 3m now and enjoyed a few recent articles about Brighton, particularly the one about Percy Tau. Naylor isn't a perfect reporter, he thought Calamity Wayne Henderson was better than FDM, but at least he's our reporter. In the last two or three weeks, I reckon he has upped his game.

Farehamseagull · Oct 23, 2020

I find the whole thing a bit disappointing in all honesty. I subscribed three months ago but won’t be extending at the end of my year.

Don’t bother going on it most days. The Brighton content is quite dull and nothing new really. I’ve never been a fan of Naylor’s writing though in all honesty, find it very predictable and basic.

As for wider football, I learn nothing new from what I hear on the various football podcasts I listen to.

AZ Gull · Oct 23, 2020

Bozza said:
Are you credited with an assist?

No, although I'd love to think he prints off my articles on here and sticks them on his noticeboard for reference! :wink:

HantsSeagull · Oct 23, 2020

interesting.....i dont subscribe but follow Naylor on twitter and he often posts a teaser link to one of his articles where i think - 'i would quite like to read that and why doesnt Brian have this stuff in the Argus'. I guess thats the point of the 'teaser' - I wont be paying to read the Stoke City fan anytime soon.

Live by the sea · Oct 23, 2020

I think the problem is twofold . Firstly with respect Andy Naylor’s journalist skills are not in the same league as some of the other sports journalists writing in the Athletic. Andy has worked almost all his career at the Argus which is not exactly stretching as a journalist, most of the articles written in the Argus are very basic .

Secondly Brighton hold their cards very close to their chests and don’t want to give out any info to Andy that they are not happy to put out to the public via their own social media etc so he will find it hard to get anything certainly of substance . Not much is leaked .

Some of the big clubs seem happy to leak info .

southstandandy · Oct 23, 2020

The articles about the Albion are very thin and like many on here I've been quite disappointed. Tried the 3 month £1 offer but haven't renewed. Naylor seems to have regressed in his writing sadly.

Skaville · Oct 23, 2020

AZ Gull said:
To be fair, I should add that at least he has now discovered that we have an U-23 and U-18 squad, with a few articles on the promising youngsters that are coming through the system.

I haven’t been impressed with much but the piece on Haydon Roberts was excellent.

Justice · Oct 23, 2020

I’m convinced Naylor doesn’t have a source at the club. Or if he does they aren’t exactly in the loop.

Paul Reids Sock · Oct 23, 2020

To me it has felt like AN is still finding his feet there. Some of his articles have been brilliant whereas others have been a bit run rate. Like others have said, he was at The Argus forever where I doubt he was encouraged to go off on long winded investigations into former players etc.

I signed up when it first went live and did the full year, then got a free month to stop me from cancelling. I cancelled anyway.

I am unsure whether to sign up again, some of the long reads on there are amazing, I spent a great afternoon in the sun reading about baseball, a sport I know very little about. Football, however, is my sport and I am not sure I want to spend much time reading about it, at the moment it appears to be disappearing up its' own arse

Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊

[Albion] The Athletic - Brighton content

Well-known member

Well-known member

Once Dolphin, Now Seagull

Habitual User

Well-known member

Well-known member

@SeagullsAcademy Threads: @bhafcacademy

Well-known member

Well-known member

@SeagullsAcademy Threads: @bhafcacademy

You can change this

Well-known member

Solly March Fan Club

@SeagullsAcademy Threads: @bhafcacademy

Well-known member

Well-known member

WEST STAND ANDY

Well-known member

Dangerous Idiot

Well-known member

Share this page