[Albion] Is it time to cash in on Lewis Dunk?

ukpolska · Jul 21, 2020

I know this is going to get a few feathers ruffled but do you think it is time to cash in on Lewis Dunk?

With players like Ben White, Adam Webster, Shane Duffy, Leo Östigard, Dan Burn and Matt Clarke all natural central defenders, do you think any of them could step up and replace Dunk?

I cannot count how many blocks Dunk has made this year in front of goal, and it makes me nervous even suggesting it, but Brighton could get a tidy penny for him which they will not get in a couple of years being that he will be 29 this year.

A bigger question might be would he want to go?

Biscuit · Jul 21, 2020

Calling [MENTION=34942]Dr. No[/MENTION]

Farehamseagull · Jul 21, 2020

No. End of thread.

Mellotron · Jul 21, 2020

Rip the beating heart of our defence out?

Nah, you're alright.

stewart12 · Jul 21, 2020

absolutely not

hart's shirt · Jul 21, 2020

Every player has his price.

Dunk's would be very high.

I wouldn't want to lose him.

Simster · Jul 21, 2020

Biscuit said:
Calling @DrNo

It's not as simple as that. We won't form a reputation for preventing players from fulfilling their potential, otherwise up and coming players won't end up signing here in the first place. If Arsenal came calling, offered £45-50m and the player wanted to go, he absolutely would go and rightly so.

Thing is, it's all speculation. Everything needs to be right - the club wanting him, the proposed fee, and Dunk's willingness to go.

papajaff · Jul 21, 2020

Icy Gull · Jul 21, 2020

Nope but if he did he would find himself in the next England squad after his transfer ...100% guaranteed imo

hans kraay fan club · Jul 21, 2020

No.

He's our best player by an astonishingly, and worryingly, wide margin.

He's worth far more to us, than anyone would pay.

Bry Nylon · Jul 21, 2020

If he wanted to go for personal and professional reasons? He'd go with my 100% support and gratitude and nothing but best wishes for all future success.

But manufacture a scenario to actively sell him? I'd need a lot of convincing that that would be the right thing to do. (But, yes. It's not my money in the club, obvs.)

Dr. No · Jul 21, 2020

ukpolska said:
I know this is going to get a few feathers ruffled but do you think it is time to cash in on Lewis Dunk?

With players like Ben White, Adam Webster, Shane Duffy, Leo Östigard, Dan Burn and Matt Clarke all natural central defenders, do you think any of them could step up and replace Dunk?

I cannot count how many blocks Dunk has made this year in front of goal, and it makes me nervous even suggesting it, but Brighton could get a tidy penny for him which they will not get in a couple of years being that he will be 29 this year.

A bigger question might be would he want to go?

Biscuit said:
Calling @DrNo

No.

Kuipers Supporters Club · Jul 21, 2020

If Chelsea offered £50M+ then I would accept it. I think Dunk deserves his chance to play for England, the club he supports and top level football.

He has more than earned it after sticking with us.

Biscuit · Jul 21, 2020

Simster said:
It's not as simple as that. We won't form a reputation for preventing players from fulfilling their potential, otherwise up and coming players won't end up signing here in the first place. If Arsenal came calling, offered £45-50m and the player wanted to go, he absolutely would go and rightly so.

Thing is, it's all speculation. Everything needs to be right - the club wanting him, the proposed fee, and Dunk's willingness to go.

That's a different question to "Is now the right time to cash in?"

If a top 6 club offer £45-50million, I doubt anyone would stand in Dunk's way. He would have deserved the move.

Farehamseagull · Jul 21, 2020

hans kraay fan club said:
No.

He's our best player by an astonishingly, and worryingly, wide margin.

He's worth far more to us, than anyone would pay.

This. He is more than just an incredibly good, consistent and brave centre back to us. He is the heartbeat of the side, if he went I would be really worried about next season whoever we signed.

schmunk · Jul 21, 2020

ukpolska said:
I cannot count how many blocks Dunk has made this year in front of goal,

Somebody can - it's 32 - joint 5th, but interestingly a LONG way behind Mings and Tarkowski...

https://www.premierleague.com/stats/top/players/outfielder_block?se=274

That said - Liverpool's top blocker is (of course) VVD, with only 15, and Man City's is Fernandinho with 16, so clearly the stat is greatly affected by the play around them...

highflyer · Jul 21, 2020

Why would we? If we need money we can get £50 quadzillion from leeds for Ben White.

dingodan · Jul 21, 2020

Off to Leeds.

I don't think we can stand in his way either, he will of course want to play in the Champions League Final.

Swansman · Jul 21, 2020

No. If he would want to leave to get a fat contract, titles, better shot at playing with England, it would be a different question. But actively trying to sell him just to "cash in" would be some stupid shit.

ukpolska · Jul 21, 2020

schmunk said:
Somebody can - it's 32 - joint 5th, but interestingly a LONG way behind Mings and Tarkowski...

https://www.premierleague.com/stats/top/players/outfielder_block?se=274

That said - Liverpool's top blocker is (of course) VVD, with only 15, and Man City's is Fernandinho with 16, so clearly the stat is greatly affected by the play around them...

That's very interesting and thanks

Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊

[Albion] Is it time to cash in on Lewis Dunk?

Well-known member

Native Creative

Solly March Fan Club

I've asked for soup

Well-known member

Well-known member

"the man's an arse"

Well-known member

Back on the rollercoaster

The voice of reason.

Test your smoke alarm

Well-known member

Well-known member

Native Creative

Solly March Fan Club

"Members"

Well-known member

New member

Pro-peace

Well-known member

Share this page