Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊
[Music] Musical tributes
- Thread starter Harry Wilson's tackle
- Start date
Raleigh Chopper
New member
Genius.
Not just the guitar playing, but the showmanship, the presence, the way he looks, the lot.
Makes me go cold watching it.
So does his live Purple Rain.
Writes, composes, produces and plays other instruments as well.
.
- Thread starter
- #23
You raise an interesting point. We all recognise that we have different tastes. However, it is tempting to slip into the trap of dismissing anything that does not meet our tastes as shit. I have certainly been guilty of it. Now, I am prepared to accept that Paul McCartney, John Denver, Whitney Huston, Val Doonican and others are not shit, but simply not to my taste. I make no comment about their intrinsic value.
At the other end of the spectrum, people can slip into the error of assuming just because someone is a virtuoso, they must be good, and deffo not shit. So I won't defend Prince on his virtuosity, ability to write and play, blah blah. Indeed, at one time, I dismissed Prince as 'shit'. The first time I heard 'Purple Rain' I though 'not for me......shit!'. But I heard it again later, not really listening, and it suddenly hit me. That bit of daylight from behind a previously closed door, let me into the world of Prince. I don't like all his stuff but at least I'm no longer a hater, and I do really love some of his ouvre.
People who say their favourite artists, however, are favourites because they are the 'best musicians' need to be slapped. I have heard this sort of rubbish said about John McLaughlin, John Coltrane, Hendrix (great virtuosos) and (more ludicrously) the members of Pink Floyd, Genesis and Fleetwood Mac. FFS, if you like it, like it, but don't 'like it' just because it makes you think you can gob off about your superior musical taste. Typically such nobs are Manchester United 'supporters'.
Anyway. . . . .and finally, I still feel I can dismiss some music as shit, and I question the humanity of the adherents. Donny Osmond, Tiny Tim, Barry Manilow.....but even with these I feel I may be being unfair to those people who love these performers and listen with pleasure to their music (presumably while engaging in auto-asphyxiation sex play).
Icy Gull
Back on the rollercoaster
- Jul 5, 2003
- 72,015
- Thread starter
- #25
boik
Well-known member
Tribute to Sara Johnson, mistress of Jilly Coopers husband, who dismissed their 6 six year affair in court as "a dalliance".
Icy Gull
Back on the rollercoaster
- Jul 5, 2003
- 72,015
Raleigh Chopper
New member
- Thread starter
- #30
Not sure if this is a tribute or just a cover. Good though.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0fMJ9EdtVJc
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0fMJ9EdtVJc
You raise an interesting point. We all recognise that we have different tastes. However, it is tempting to slip into the trap of dismissing anything that does not meet our tastes as shit. I have certainly been guilty of it. Now, I am prepared to accept that Paul McCartney, John Denver, Whitney Huston, Val Doonican and others are not shit, but simply not to my taste. I make no comment about their intrinsic value.
At the other end of the spectrum, people can slip into the error of assuming just because someone is a virtuoso, they must be good, and deffo not shit. So I won't defend Prince on his virtuosity, ability to write and play, blah blah. Indeed, at one time, I dismissed Prince as 'shit'. The first time I heard 'Purple Rain' I though 'not for me......shit!'. But I heard it again later, not really listening, and it suddenly hit me. That bit of daylight from behind a previously closed door, let me into the world of Prince. I don't like all his stuff but at least I'm no longer a hater, and I do really love some of his ouvre.
People who say their favourite artists, however, are favourites because they are the 'best musicians' need to be slapped. I have heard this sort of rubbish said about John McLaughlin, John Coltrane, Hendrix (great virtuosos) and (more ludicrously) the members of Pink Floyd, Genesis and Fleetwood Mac. FFS, if you like it, like it, but don't 'like it' just because it makes you think you can gob off about your superior musical taste. Typically such nobs are Manchester United 'supporters'.
Anyway. . . . .and finally, I still feel I can dismiss some music as shit, and I question the humanity of the adherents. Donny Osmond, Tiny Tim, Barry Manilow.....but even with these I feel I may be being unfair to those people who love these performers and listen with pleasure to their music (presumably while engaging in auto-asphyxiation sex play).
That trait was so typical of fans of Black Sabbath. Led Zeppelin and Deep Purple. Fans who loved that sound, simply couldn’t accept that the music from the creative geniuses in many post punk and new wave bands was any cop ... because they’re not great technicians.
The overall sound of a track, its originality, the vocals, the lyrics, the melody, beat, harmony, all variously hit the soul of the listener. Who doesn’t give a **** about the classical training or technical credentials of the musicians. Giving us the beautifully diverse pop of the last 50 plus years.
Return of the Rev
Well-known member
Raleigh Chopper
New member
- Jul 10, 2003
- 25,843
I've always loved that. The look on Tom Petty/Steve Winwood/Jeff Lynne's faces is an absolute picture
And, as if it couldn't get any better, it's got my favourite Brighton born and bred drummer on it