Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊

Register Log in

[Albion] The Poll Of The Season! The Players!

Who is good enough?

  • Ryan

    Votes: 224 86.8%

  • Button

    Votes: 88 34.1%

  • Steele

    Votes: 24 9.3%

  • Dunk

    Votes: 251 97.3%

  • Duffy

    Votes: 247 95.7%

  • Burn

    Votes: 151 58.5%

  • Balogun

    Votes: 97 37.6%

  • Bong

    Votes: 130 50.4%

  • Bernardo

    Votes: 237 91.9%

  • Montoya

    Votes: 132 51.2%

  • Stephens

    Votes: 130 50.4%

  • Kayal

    Votes: 89 34.5%

  • Propper

    Votes: 186 72.1%

  • Bissouma

    Votes: 242 93.8%

  • Gross

    Votes: 185 71.7%

  • March

    Votes: 233 90.3%

  • Knockaert

    Votes: 153 59.3%

  • Izquierdo

    Votes: 143 55.4%

  • Jahanbakhsh

    Votes: 76 29.5%

  • Locadia

    Votes: 64 24.8%

  • Murray

    Votes: 128 49.6%

  • Andone

    Votes: 166 64.3%
  • Total voters
    258


The GIF dude

The GIF dude

New member
Mar 22, 2013
202
Sidwell
Murray 68 votes.
Andone 95 votes.

Murray - 13 premier league goals this season. As many as Lacazette.
Andone - 3 premier league goals this season.
 






A1X

A1X

Well-known member
NSC Patron
Sep 1, 2017
17,840
Deepest, darkest Sussex
Poor old Jason Steele
 


E

Exile

Objective but passionate
Aug 10, 2014
2,367
the right footed denilson said:
Burn more votes than Montoya...
Click to expand...

See - this is because you didn't clearly set out the context for voting. Are they 'good enough?' for WHAT?

In the absence of that, I answered as 'are they good enough for their CURRENT roles?'

As such I voted that yes, Burn IS good enough, to be a back up CB, and that no, Montoya is NOT good enough to be our starting right back.

It doesn't follow that I think Burn is necessarily BETTER than Montoya...
 


the right footed denilson

the right footed denilson

New member
Jul 5, 2003
6,776
Bristol
Exile said:
See - this is because you didn't clearly set out the context for voting. Are they 'good enough?' for WHAT?

In the absence of that, I answered as 'are they good enough for their CURRENT roles?'

As such I voted that yes, Burn IS good enough, to be a back up CB, and that no, Montoya is NOT good enough to be our starting right back.

It doesn't follow that I think Burn is necessarily BETTER than Montoya...
Click to expand...
I'm sorry for letting everyone down.
 














Pavilionaire

Pavilionaire

Well-known member
Jul 7, 2003
30,588
Kman said:
Leave things to the future Manager as he knows more.
Click to expand...

That doesn't make for a very interesting message board.
 


K

Kman

New member
Mar 30, 2019
215
Pavilionaire said:
That doesn't make for a very interesting message board.
Click to expand...

Well okay. First off, I wouldn't ship out the new signings until I see them under a new manager/system. The only players I would let go right now would be Knockaert and Stephens as I feel the rest are good enough.
 






Pavilionaire

Pavilionaire

Well-known member
Jul 7, 2003
30,588
Kman said:
Well okay. First off, I wouldn't ship out the new signings until I see them under a new manager/system. The only players I would let go right now would be Knockaert and Stephens as I feel the rest are good enough.
Click to expand...

So beloved manager gets sacked and the players that carry the can are Knockaert and Stephens, while Locadia and Jahanbaksh get another chance? I can't see that doing much for team morale.
 








A1X

A1X

Well-known member
NSC Patron
Sep 1, 2017
17,840
Deepest, darkest Sussex
I think a lot of the problem with this is about people deciding what their role is.

Take Glenn. Is he good enough to be our #1 striker next season? No, I'd argue he's not, and the second half of this season has proved it. However is he good enough to be our third choice striker and potential "impact" sub for the last 15 minutes if we need a goal and want someone to lump it up to? Yes, absolutely, for another season anyway.
 


the right footed denilson

the right footed denilson

New member
Jul 5, 2003
6,776
Bristol
A1X said:
I think a lot of the problem with this is about people deciding what their role is.

Take Glenn. Is he good enough to be our #1 striker next season? No, I'd argue he's not, and the second half of this season has proved it. However is he good enough to be our third choice striker and potential "impact" sub for the last 15 minutes if we need a goal and want someone to lump it up to? Yes, absolutely, for another season anyway.
Click to expand...
Then he is 'good enough'.

What this really highlights is that we only have 5/6 players that are universally deemed worth a place in the squad. Imho that is surprising.
Edit: maybe Gross and Propper too.
 


perseus

perseus

Broad Blue & White stripe
Jul 5, 2003
23,457
Sūþseaxna
No options for recent retirees and loan rangers
 




Peter Grummit

Peter Grummit

Well-known member
Oct 13, 2004
6,769
Lewes
the right footed denilson said:
100 votes up and my bedtime.
Dunk - 99 votes.
Duffy - 98
Yves - 94
Bernardo and March - 90
Ryan - 87...
But apart from those seriously heavy hitters? Not much.
Maybe Hughton wasn't so bad....
Click to expand...
I've said on other threads I'd like to see the team built around these 6 players. Recruit 5 more quality starters and complete the squad with Walton, Button, Montoya, Bong, Burn, Balogun, Stephens, Propper, Knocky, Izqueirdo, Ali J, Murray, Andone, Locadia. Sell Kayal.

Whether the budget runs to this I don't know! If not, sell Locadia and Ali J and cut our losses.

Sent from my SM-G930F using Tapatalk
 


perseus

perseus

Broad Blue & White stripe
Jul 5, 2003
23,457
Sūþseaxna
Popular team: (9/11 mine as well)

Ryan
Montoya Duffy Dunk Bong
Bissouma Pröpper Bernardo
Groß
Andone March​
 


You must log in or register to reply here.

Share this page

Albion and Premier League latest from Sky Sports


Top
Link Here