[Albion] 5, 6, 7 players need to go!

Nixonator · Apr 13, 2019

Yea let's oust all our players.

This will be a list of everyone's least favourite players and very little merit involved in ascertaining whether they are 'PL' quality, if there is such a thing.

A team can be PL quality, like Burnley, with only a handful of players that most people would declare the same about on an individual level.

Our squad is decent enough (just about) to stay in this division, bottom line.

I am more inclined to fault how the players are being instructed, than to pick holes in the ability of individuals who will all obviously have glaring faults because they are playing for us, and not Man City.

Weststander · Apr 13, 2019

Dale Jasper said:
Dunk, Duffy and to a lesser extent Ryan look a class apart from the rest of the squad

Sadly, I think you’re right.

They’d fit into any midtable PL first team.

Imagine the luxury for them, playing with a PL midfield and fullbacks.

mattislost · Apr 13, 2019

Guinness Boy said:
Ryan, Duffy, Dunk, Gross, Izquiero are PL quality

Montoya is borderline

Bissouma and Bernardo will be absolute mustard with a bit more PL experience

Andone? Jury's out. Can't survive on three good games a season but has been injury plagued.

Everyone else must be made available.

Izquierdo, who managed to kick the ball in his own face whilst trying to shoot today?

madinthehead · Apr 13, 2019

Guinness Boy said:
Ryan, Duffy, Dunk, Gross, Izquiero are PL quality

Montoya is borderline

Bissouma and Bernardo will be absolute mustard with a bit more PL experience

Andone? Jury's out. Can't survive on three good games a season but has been injury plagued.

Everyone else must be made available.

Pretty much agree, but I still think Izquierdo also belongs to the Jurys Out club

martin tyler · Apr 13, 2019

You have to move players on and progress the squad.
I’d personally let Montoya (some of his positioning for a right back is baffling at times)
Knockaert - seems in a paradox to good for championship but not good enough for PL and he is to petulant
Propper - potentially keep but isn’t mobile enough especially alongside Gross and Stephens
Stephens - mobile upgrade needed
Gross - same as above
Locadia 18 months little to show for it cut losses move him on
Andone and Murray i would but neither should be 1st choice

Bong Hemed Kayal balogun need moving along as well

We also need to fit players to the way we plan to play
This 433 451 appears to suit very few of our signings and we end up players plying in the wrong place

Murray 17 · Apr 13, 2019

dadams2k11 said:
I think the story about disharmony in the changing room as some weight to it.

Does anyone know what/who has caused this?

drew · Apr 13, 2019

Sorry but for the first half of the seasons the players were good enough to hold their own. From a economical point of view, it will be far cheaper to change a manager that isn't performing than it will be to change pretty much the entire squad as some seem to suggest.

The players lack direction and motivation. Can only mean one thing.

Justice · Apr 13, 2019

Murray 17 said:
Does anyone know what/who has caused this?

Heard Murray and other senior players confronted CH about his negative football tactics. Didn’t get any joy apparently for a change of formation.

BensGrandad · Apr 13, 2019

WA is probably right but where do you start and do we want 6 or 7 players bought on the cheap who prove to be no better than what we have.

Pavilionaire · Apr 13, 2019

The home form has fallen off a cliff and that's a worry. Chris changed the tactics today - understandably - but it's backfired. Some of the players look like they've reached their natural limit, i.e Knockaert, Stephens, Kayal and there's nothing wrong with that, but we don't know if there's more to come from Ali J, Locadia, Andone, Bissouma.

The bottom line is we have the biggest game of the season coming up on Tuesday and the natural inclination is to go with players who will fight for the shirt - and that doesn't include many of our expensive acquisitions.

One Teddy Maybank · Apr 13, 2019

Guinness Boy said:
Ryan, Duffy, Dunk, Gross, Izquiero are PL quality

Montoya is borderline

Bissouma and Bernardo will be absolute mustard with a bit more PL experience

Andone? Jury's out. Can't survive on three good games a season but has been injury plagued.

Everyone else must be made available.

I don’t rate Ryan at this moment in time, poor since January.

Izquierdo is a one trick pony.

I’d keep Propper as well.

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Guinness Boy · Apr 13, 2019

mattislost said:
Izquierdo, who managed to kick the ball in his own face whilst trying to shoot today?

madinthehead said:
Pretty much agree, but I still think Izquierdo also belongs to the Jurys Out club

He's not fit. The guy who played in the second half of last season and took West Ham to bits twice is PL class. The guy who's been injured since the World Cup? Not so much. But I would keep him. He's shown he can do it. Unlike Ali J and Locadia who have show repeatedly that they're not up to it

Weststander · Apr 13, 2019

Johnny Cantor tonight said that we have a bottom 3 player wages budget.

Which reflects in the very often substandard first team, play and squad.

Of course we need to move on from that this summer.

Norwich, and quite possibly Leeds and Villa, will get promoted this summer. The PL is about to get even more competitive.

All the chronically weak squads (including either Cardiff or Brighton) would’ve been removed from the PL by this summer - Sunderland, WBA, Hudd, Swansea, Cardiff/Brighton, Fulham.

If we stay up, TB’s going to have to up the ante for 2019/20.

Weststander · Apr 13, 2019

drew said:
Sorry but for the first half of the seasons the players were good enough to hold their own. From a economical point of view, it will be far cheaper to change a manager that isn't performing than it will be to change pretty much the entire squad as some seem to suggest.

The players lack direction and motivation. Can only mean one thing.

CH recently said at a fans Q&A evening, that “we were outplayed by Newcastle, Wolves and West Ham”. He was honest and realistic enough about those wins. 2019 has shown our true level.

Springal · Apr 13, 2019

The problem is, if we are to get rid of players where do they go? All on Prem wages and we know Dutch / German / Spanish teams can’t afford to pay that. If we go down we are stuck with most of this squad

Doc Lynam · Apr 13, 2019

I guess the question is does TB want to go to the next level financially with the squad!

Tom Hark Preston Park · Apr 13, 2019

mattislost said:
Izquierdo, who managed to kick the ball in his own face whilst trying to shoot today?

Best - and just about only - laugh of the day. How on earth did he DO that? :lolol:

Weststander · Apr 13, 2019

Doc Lynam said:
I guess the question is does TB want to go to the next level financially with the squad!

Well, Winstanley, Bloom and Barber have a huge say in signings, CH didn’t scout Holland to come up with Propper, Locadia and Jahanbakhsh.

Does TB have faith in the current system in general and scouting, with the next big spend?

Simster · Apr 13, 2019

Guinness Boy said:
Ryan, Duffy, Dunk, Gross, Izquiero are PL quality

Montoya is borderline

Bissouma and Bernardo will be absolute mustard with a bit more PL experience

Andone? Jury's out. Can't survive on three good games a season but has been injury plagued.

Everyone else must be made available.

Almost exactly where I am, to the man. I'd add Solly March to your Premier quality list though.

A1X · Apr 13, 2019

Pavilionaire said:
The home form has fallen off a cliff and that's a worry. Chris changed the tactics today - understandably - but it's backfired. Some of the players look like they've reached their natural limit, i.e Knockaert, Stephens, Kayal and there's nothing wrong with that, but we don't know if there's more to come from Ali J, Locadia, Andone, Bissouma.

The bottom line is we have the biggest game of the season coming up on Tuesday and the natural inclination is to go with players who will fight for the shirt - and that doesn't include many of our expensive acquisitions.

Bit harsh to drag Kayal into that when he doesn't get game time.

Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊

[Albion] 5, 6, 7 players need to go!

Well-known member

Well-known member

Active member

I have changed this

Well-known member

Well-known member

Drew

Dangerous Idiot

New member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Tofu eating wokerati

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

I hate the Daily Mail

Will Post For Cash

Well-known member

"the man's an arse"

Well-known member

Share this page