Geestar
New member
May have seen this last season...
Sent from my TA-1020 using Tapatalk
Sent from my TA-1020 using Tapatalk
Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊
[Football] Refereeing standards.
- Thread starter lawros left foot
- Start date
Thunder Bolt
Silly old bat
It's the inconsistency that upsets me especially now retrospective action is taken. Lukaku not punished for his assault on Bong, for example.
In real time, officials are human, and will make mistakes, but if footage is going to be used for suspensions then punish all the culprits, not just some of them.
In real time, officials are human, and will make mistakes, but if footage is going to be used for suspensions then punish all the culprits, not just some of them.
- Dec 7, 2017
- 224
I would say there are three areas where refereeing of the game is not good.
First are the obvious bad decisions. VAR will help with these, but a team of highly-paid professionals should be able to spot these regardless.
Second are the on-the-pitch inconsistencies. You can't watch a game nowadays without referees letting one thing go then punishing a similar offence later on, decisions on fouls depending on where on the pitch they occur, and more.
Third are the off-the-pitch inconsistencies. The obvious example of this is that if an incident is in a referee's report no further action will be taken, but if not then a separate punishment can be given out. This allows players to get away with cheating, plain and simple.
I don't want to watch football to see who can get away with what, I want to see skill on and off the ball. The application of the laws needs to change so that it is consistent and cheating is properly punished.
First are the obvious bad decisions. VAR will help with these, but a team of highly-paid professionals should be able to spot these regardless.
Second are the on-the-pitch inconsistencies. You can't watch a game nowadays without referees letting one thing go then punishing a similar offence later on, decisions on fouls depending on where on the pitch they occur, and more.
Third are the off-the-pitch inconsistencies. The obvious example of this is that if an incident is in a referee's report no further action will be taken, but if not then a separate punishment can be given out. This allows players to get away with cheating, plain and simple.
I don't want to watch football to see who can get away with what, I want to see skill on and off the ball. The application of the laws needs to change so that it is consistent and cheating is properly punished.
I'm honestly not sure. I think if you'd asked me a season or two ago I would have been more confident in saying no. There are as many errors as there have always been, we just moved on and forgot about them in the past, either because we later benefited from mistakes, or because at the end of the season it didn't really cost us (or couldn't easily be pointed at the reason we finished where we did), or just because of the passage of time.
I'm inclined to think that is still the case, that a lot of the mistakes we're pointing to now will be forgotten by the end of the season (especially if we start getting results and stay up relatively comfortably), and next year when they happen in the safe frequency we'll start asking this question again.
Like I said in my first response, I'm can certainly understand that it feels like we're seeing more mistakes. Maybe it's that the mistakes are happening in our games more frequently than in the past but less frequently elsewhere so that overall it's no different it just feels worse from our perspective.
I actually think the assistants are more to blame, they stand there closer to some of these calls and do nothing.
lawros left foot
Glory hunting since 1969
- Thread starter
- #27
This, the inconsistency that sees Tomer Hemed ‘stamp’ last season on Lascelles(?) punished with a 3 game ban, and Tyrone Mings ‘ accidental tread’ on Nelson Oliveria not even being called in is bizarre, and calls the FAs whole retrospective disciplinary procedure into question.
That the Zaha stamp on Andone couldn’t be called in because his initial foul on Andone was punished with a free kick is a nonsense.
lawros left foot
Glory hunting since 1969
- Thread starter
- #28
I only use our club as an example of awful officiating as I watch our games more, and pay more attention, but I’m really talking about across the whole of PL football
Assistants are too scared to give anyhing now. The one in front of East Stand must have seen the handball yesterday. The 4th official totally pointless role too.
Icy Gull
Back on the rollercoaster
- Jul 5, 2003
- 72,015
Hmm brave enough to tell the ref to reverse the corner into a goal kick though...or was that the West Stand one, I was watching on a stream so may have mixed them up.
brightn'ove
cringe
this has been the case though for about 10 years. I'd be interested to hear the actual statistics on accuracy in the past few seasons - it FEELS like it's got worse, but it could just be hype/spin.
Think also in days gone by you'd have maybe 2 cameras covering the match and now there seem to be dozens so you get to see the same incident from every conceivable angle.
A nothing decision really, they hardly give pens etc