[Albion] VAR to feature in Albion's Carabao Cup tie v Southampton

T

Tooting Gull

Well-known member

Jul 5, 2003

11,033

• Aug 23, 2018

• #1

One of four ties where it will be used, so multiple matches (three) on Tuesday night for first time in this country. Referee Andre Marriner, and VAR 'expert', it's Stuart 'ghost goal' Attwell.

To assist ref only in goals, penalty/no penalty decisions, direct red cards shown or not shown, and mistaken identity. Original decision only changed if clear and obvious error, we'll be kept up to speed on the screens.

 

Shirty

Daring to Zlatan

Jan 18, 2006

912

Arriving somewhere, but not here

• Aug 23, 2018

• #2

Dont think its the first time in this country. Didnt we have VAR for the Palace FA Cup match last year ?

 

S

Springal

Well-known member

Feb 12, 2005

23,830

GOSBTS

• Aug 23, 2018

• #3

Shirty said:

Didnt we have VAR for the Palace FA Cup match last year ?

Click to expand...

Yes. Far from first time in this country. First time in the Carabao cup? Maybe but surprised the final didn't have it last year at lelast

 

Is it PotG?

Thrifty non-licker

Feb 20, 2017

23,270

Sussex by the Sea

• Aug 23, 2018

• #4

 

Papa Lazarou

Living in a De Zerbi wonderland

Jul 7, 2003

18,853

Worthing

• Aug 23, 2018

• #5

Tooting Gull said:

One of four ties where it will be used, so multiple matches (three) on Tuesday night for first time in this country. Referee Andre Marriner, and VAR 'expert', it's Stuart 'ghost goal' Attwell.

To assist ref only in goals, penalty/no penalty decisions, direct red cards shown or not shown, and mistaken identity. Original decision only changed if clear and obvious error, we'll be kept up to speed on the screens.

Click to expand...

not offsides?

 

T

Tooting Gull

Well-known member

Jul 5, 2003

11,033

• Aug 23, 2018

• Thread starter
• #6

Multiple...for the first time.

 

M

Munkfish

Well-known member

May 1, 2006

11,871

• Aug 23, 2018

• #7

Shirty said:

Dont think its the first time in this country. Didnt we have VAR for the Palace FA Cup match last year ?

Click to expand...

I think it means multiple games at once

 

T

Tooting Gull

Well-known member

Jul 5, 2003

11,033

• Aug 23, 2018

• Thread starter
• #8

Papa Lazarou said:

not offsides?

Click to expand...

Nope, apparently not...

 

Easy 10

Brain dead MUG SHEEP

Jul 5, 2003

61,747

Location Location

• Aug 23, 2018

• #9

Papa Lazarou said:

not offsides?

Click to expand...

Only if a goal is scored which turns out to be offside, or is ruled out for offside when it was onside. I think.

 

T

timbha

Well-known member

Jul 5, 2003

9,884

Sussex

• Aug 23, 2018

• #10

Is it PotG? said:

View attachment 100021

Click to expand...

Hiney?

 

B

Blues Rock DJ

New member

Apr 18, 2011

4,007

Dorset

• Aug 23, 2018

• #11

is it on tele ?

 

The Large One

Who's Next?

Jul 7, 2003

52,343

97.2FM

• Aug 23, 2018

• #12

Papa Lazarou said:

not offsides?

Click to expand...

Never was for offside decisions, except in the build-up to a goal.

 

J

Jim D

Well-known member

Jul 23, 2003

5,249

Worthing

• Aug 23, 2018

• #13

The Large One said:

Never was for offside decisions, except in the build-up to a goal.

Click to expand...

But are we now going to have the Lino's being told not to give offside and leave it to the Var ref? Not sure I like that idea.

 

Wilko

LUZZING chairs about

Sep 19, 2003

9,922

BN1

• Aug 23, 2018

• #14

Jim D said:

But are we now going to have the Lino's being told not to give offside and leave it to the Var ref? Not sure I like that idea.

Click to expand...

As in the WC, if it’s marginal then they play on and review after if a goal has been scored.

 

TSB

Captain Hindsight

Jul 7, 2003

17,666

Lansdowne Place, Hove

• Aug 23, 2018

• #15

Best referee in England in charge.

We had this for Palace in the cup, right? And it was used a total of zero times?

 

The Large One

Who's Next?

Jul 7, 2003

52,343

97.2FM

• Aug 23, 2018

• #16

Jim D said:

But are we now going to have the Lino's being told not to give offside and leave it to the Var ref? Not sure I like that idea.

Click to expand...

Cobblers, innit?

 

jonny.rainbow

Well-known member

Oct 29, 2005

6,603

• Aug 23, 2018

• #17

TSB said:

Best referee in England in charge.

We had this for Palace in the cup, right? And it was used a total of zero times?

Click to expand...

The VAR was used in that match to confirm Murray didn’t handle the ball and that there were no fouls or offsides in the buildup.

The RRA (Referee Review Area) was not used.

 

T

TheJasperCo

Well-known member

Jan 20, 2012

4,590

Exeter

• Aug 24, 2018

• #18

I''ve always maintained I hate VAR, but as with other technology, if it's going to be imposed on us there's not a lot we can do about it. Although I do hope it dies a death, I think there's too much being invested in the system to just scrap it now. Guess we can only hope that it does improve the game over time, and that VAR-related controversies are kept to a minimum (or, zero - preferably).