[Albion] Should we appeal the Propper red?

A1X · Apr 7, 2018

Not seen the incident myself but opinion seems to be that it was harsh. The games he'll miss are;

Palace (A)
Spurs (H)
Burnley (A)

It strikes me that it has to be worth the appeal, as if the extra game is given it's Man Utd and a game we might not expect anything from anyway. Worth the risk?

Washie · Apr 7, 2018

A1X said:
Not seen the incident myself but opinion seems to be that it was harsh. The games he'll miss are;

Palace (A)
Spurs (H)
Burnley (A)

It strikes me that it has to be worth the appeal, as if the extra game is given it's Man Utd and a game we might not expect anything from anyway. Worth the risk?

Yes

AmexRuislip · Apr 7, 2018

Mellotron · Apr 7, 2018

Definitely. Was 15 yards in front of me. Firm yellow in my opinion.

StonehamPark · Apr 7, 2018

Total 50-50 challenge.
Appeal it.

Seagull kimchi · Apr 7, 2018

Never get overturned unless a clear mistaken identity or no contact - otherwise forget it - refs are always backed.

Bodian · Apr 7, 2018

Given the appeals panels other decisions where we have been involved, I can't see them overturning this. He did slide in with studs up. Probably should have been a yellow only, but I reckon any panel will say something along the lines of 'can see why the ref has done that' and so they won't overturn it. Be nice if they did mind you.

midnight_rendezvous · Apr 7, 2018

Seagull kimchi said:
Never get overturned unless a clear mistaken identity or no contact - otherwise forget it - refs are always backed.

Sadly, this.

Sorrel · Apr 7, 2018

It won't be overturned.

Titanic · Apr 7, 2018

Seagull kimchi said:
Never get overturned unless a clear mistaken identity or no contact - otherwise forget it - refs are always backed.

This, unfortunately.

martin tyler · Apr 7, 2018

Yes. BBC thought yellow as did sky. From my position he was late but one footed, in control and studs were not raised. Considering the ref wasn’t exactly a fan of blowing for fouls he seemed desperate to give a red and that little shit Pritchard had to have his 2 pence worth.
Spineless FA will do sod all though

maltaseagull · Apr 7, 2018

Seagull kimchi said:
Never get overturned unless a clear mistaken identity or no contact - otherwise forget it - refs are always backed.

Sadly, you are correct.
Ref are very rarely over ruled.

lizard · Apr 7, 2018

Yeah, let's give the FA the chance to make it 5.

GloryDays · Apr 7, 2018

Appeal it? No.

Should it have been a red? No.

Will, on 2nd viewing by the authorities, it be considered a red? Yes

Mr deez · Apr 7, 2018

Never get overturned but given it's end of season and I don't think we've appealed anything so far, why not.

TSB · Apr 7, 2018

Sorrel said:
It won't be overturned.

We still should. Principal. It was a crap decision.

GT49er · Apr 7, 2018

A1X said:
Should we appeal the Propper red?

Absolutely no point at all; complete waste of time.

Seasider78 · Apr 7, 2018

We will appeal it and rightly so but it won’t be rescinded

Bozza · Apr 7, 2018

Replay in the concourse suggests some stud to shin. No malice in it, clearly, but a red in the modern game.

KingKev · Apr 7, 2018

Same as others - was never a red but equally will not get overturned. I think we have to take the gamble and appeal it as we have no cover whatsoever in cm now...

Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊

[Albion] Should we appeal the Propper red?

Well-known member

Well-known member

Trainee Spy 🕵️‍♂️

I've asked for soup

#Brighton-Nil

New member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Super Moderator

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-hung member

Well-known member

Masterchef

Captain Hindsight

Well-known member

Well-known member

You can change this

Well-known member

Share this page