[Albion] Player ratings v Man Utd (a)

Hammer15 · Nov 25, 2017

Fill your boots. I'm behind on the season spreadsheet but will catch up after the Palace game.

Here for your cut & paste needs:

Ryan
Bruno
Duffy
Dunk
Bong
Knockaert
Gross
Stephens
Pröpper
March
Murray

Izquierdo
Hemed
Brown

SeagullsD123 · Nov 25, 2017

Ryan - 8 - Fantastic double save - Could not do much about the goal
Bruno - 7 - Looked very calm on the ball, pace of the game a little too fast nearer the end and Bruno struggled to keep up
Duffy - 8 - Back to his best
Dunk - 8 - Once again very good, great passing, unlucky with the goal
Bong - 7 - Like Bruno very good on the ball
Knockaert - 9 - What a performance, best this season. Tremendous skill to show he can play his usual game in the Prem
Gross - 7 - Competent performance, though set-pieces were a little off today
Stephens - 8 - Everywhere the ball was, Stephens was. Played far better than Pogba.
Pröpper - 7 - Some great dribbles, just needs to get into be running onto the balls March, Knockaert, Izquierdo and Gross are putting in.
March - 7 - Good defensively, little quiet going forward.
Murray - 7 - Got into good positions but needs to finish chances and control discipline

Izquierdo - 7 - Look bright when on
Hemed - 6 - Not much to talk about
Brown - 6 - As above

Albion Robster · Nov 25, 2017

Ryan - 7. That double save was world class. Organised and commanded his area well.

Bruno - 6. Comfortable. Didn’t really get targeted down his side. Worked well with Knocky defensively and offensively.

Dunk - 7. Just the usual Dunk performance. Lovely Lawrenson-esq run in the second half. So unlucky for the deflected goal.

Duffy - 8. Won so many headers. Offered threat at set pieces.

Bong - 7. Looked solid. Didn’t get over ran and pulled out of position. Struggles with the five yard pass!

Knockaert - 8. Back to the old Knocky. Full of running and kept his width.

Stephens - 8. Tackled and passed all game. Looks so comfortable at this level.

Propper - 8. Covered every blade of grass by 60 min mark. Lovely first-time toe poke pass to Knocky in second half.

Groß - 8. What an engine. Always provided options and distributed the ball. Couple of lovely crosses. His Cruyf turns are simply majestic!

March - 5. I think the big occasion got to him. Went missing. Should have wellied the ball out for the corner which led to their goal.

Murray - 7. Always provided an outlet. Bullied the United centre-backs. Unlucky not to get on the end of a couple of crosses.

Subs
Izquierdo - 6. Offered much more than March. Used his pace to stretch United.
Hemed - 5. Hardly got into game. Couple of flicks.
Brown - N/A. Maybe should have come on early for Propper, as Davy looked drainer around 75 mins.

Fans: 9. Sang for the whole 90mins.
Chant of the afternoon ‘We support our local team’ aimed at all the day trippers from Sweden and Holland.

seagulls4ever · Nov 25, 2017

Albion Robster said:
Ryan - 7. That double save was world class. Organised and commanded his area well.

Bruno - 6. Comfortable. Didn’t really get targeted down his side. Worked well with Knocky defensively and offensively.

Dunk - 7. Just the usual Dunk performance. Lovely Lawrenson-esq run in the second half. So unlucky for the deflected goal.

Duffy - 8. Won so many headers. Offered threat at set pieces.

Bong - 7. Looked solid. Didn’t get over ran and pulled out of position. Struggles with the five yard pass!

Knockaert - 8. Back to the old Knocky. Full of running and kept his width.

Stephens - 8. Tackled and passed all game. Looks so comfortable at this level.

Propper - 8. Covered every blade of grass by 60 min mark. Lovely first-time toe poke pass to Knocky in second half.

Groß - 8. What an engine. Always provided options and distributed the ball. Couple of lovely crosses. His Cruyf turns are simply majestic!

March - 5. I think the big occasion got to him. Went missing. Should have wellied the ball out for the corner which led to their goal.

Murray - 7. Always provided an outlet. Bullied the United centre-backs. Unlucky not to get on the end of a couple of crosses.

Subs
Izquierdo - 6. Offered much more than March. Used his pace to stretch United.
Hemed - 5. Hardly got into game. Couple of flicks.
Brown - N/A. Maybe should have come on early for Propper, as Davy looked drainer around 75 mins.

Fans: 9. Sang for the whole 90mins.
Chant of the afternoon ‘We support our local team’ aimed at all the day trippers from Sweden and Holland.

Mostly agree with those ratings.

I don't think March really did anything wrong when he tried to allow the ball to go for a goal kick, but shortly before, when we were attacking, he needlessly passed the ball straight to United in their half, which allowed them to counter.

Whitechapel · Nov 25, 2017

Albion Robster said:
Chant of the afternoon ‘We support our local team’ aimed at all the day trippers from Sweden and Holland.

Really?

It's about as boring and predictable as "Sheepshaggers" against Cardiff/Swansea or the general homophobic crap we get*.One of those where the fans of the team you sung it against probably rolled there eyes and muttered about how original it was. Would have genuinely been more impressed if our fans hadn't sunk to the levels of such boring, predictable shit but each to their own.

*I'm not saying that it is as offensive as homophobic chant, merely pointing out how unoriginal and boring it is.

Joshski · Nov 25, 2017

Full re-run of the game on Sky Sports Nissan Game of the Day, in currently will also be on demand!

Skaville · Nov 25, 2017

Ryan -7 - had bizarrrely little to do, thanks to a combination of a United off day and a masterclass in defending but did well with the double save, their only real chance. Bizarre that he got stick for time wasting given what we see week in week out at the Amex

Bruno - 7 - I have to admit that I was worried when I saw him on the teamsheet given United’s pace, but he kept Martial quiet and got forward well too. Exceptional cross right across the corridor of uncertainty that no one attacked in the last ten minutes

Duffy - 8 - colossal

Dunk - 8 - so unlucky for the goal. Was brilliant yet again. Nearly got on the end of a counter attack that was entirely of his creation. Would have been a wonder goal

Bong -7 - I’m beginning to wonder if this is the same Gaetan Bong who looked dodgy in the Championship. Excellent

Knockeart - 8 - a united mate of mine asked me what our Anthony ‘does’ after the stoke game. The same guy singled him out for praise today.

Gross - 8 - everywhere. What a signing

Stephens - 8 - seemed to have a lot of time and space against Matic and Pogba. Strange!

Pröpper - 7 - broke up play well. Another committed performance

March - 6 - most things came down our right rather than our left. A good, unspectacular shift

Murray - 7 - a proper nuisance. Looked entirely spent when he came off. Get in that oxygen tent Glenn

Izquierdo - 6 - lively
Hemed - 5 - very little impact. Disappointed he didn’t attack that Bruno cross
Brown - too little time on the pitch

Nixonator · Nov 25, 2017

Whitechapel said:
Really?

It's about as boring and predictable as "Sheepshaggers" against Cardiff/Swansea or the general homophobic crap we get*.One of those where the fans of the team you sung it against probably rolled there eyes and muttered about how original it was. Would have genuinely been more impressed if our fans hadn't sunk to the levels of such boring, predictable shit but each to their own.

*I'm not saying that it is as offensive as homophobic chant, merely pointing out how unoriginal and boring it is.

Comparing it to homophobic chants and implied bestiality... ok.

First of all we weren’t being directly offensive (heaven ****ing forbid) and is simply a statement of truth, with implication that it isn’t true for large part of the other 67k present, which is also undoubtedly accurate.

You must be a right laugh.

Hotchilidog · Nov 25, 2017

8’s all round with March having an off day at 6. Great team performance. Everyone contributed to the effort today

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Petee · Nov 25, 2017

Ryan 7
Bruno 8 MOTM
Duffy 8
Dunk 8
Bong 8
Knockaert 7.5
Propper 7.5
Stephens 7.5
March 6
Groß 8
Murray 7.5

Izquierdo 6
Hemed 6
Brown NA

One Teddy Maybank · Nov 25, 2017

Just got back, so proud of our team and supporters.

6 - average

Ryan 7
Bruno 9
Dunk 9
Duffy 9
Bong 8
Knockaert 9
Stephens 8
Propper 8
March 6
Gross 9
Murray 9 MoM.

Brown N/A
Hemed 6
Izquierdo 6

These may appear over marked to some, but the collective effort was absolutely immense.

Pogba so ordinary, and a bit of a grizzly child. Lukaku anonymous, Rashford dangerous, but don’t recall him getting past Bong......

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Buzzer · Nov 25, 2017

Whitechapel said:
Really?

It's about as boring and predictable as "Sheepshaggers" against Cardiff/Swansea or the general homophobic crap we get*.One of those where the fans of the team you sung it against probably rolled there eyes and muttered about how original it was. Would have genuinely been more impressed if our fans hadn't sunk to the levels of such boring, predictable shit but each to their own.

*I'm not saying that it is as offensive as homophobic chant, merely pointing out how unoriginal and boring it is.

Utter rubbish.

dazzer6666 · Nov 25, 2017

Albion Robster said:
Ryan - 7. That double save was world class. Organised and commanded his area well.

Bruno - 6. Comfortable. Didn’t really get targeted down his side. Worked well with Knocky defensively and offensively.

Dunk - 7. Just the usual Dunk performance. Lovely Lawrenson-esq run in the second half. So unlucky for the deflected goal.

Duffy - 8. Won so many headers. Offered threat at set pieces.

Bong - 7. Looked solid. Didn’t get over ran and pulled out of position. Struggles with the five yard pass!

Knockaert - 8. Back to the old Knocky. Full of running and kept his width.

Stephens - 8. Tackled and passed all game. Looks so comfortable at this level.

Propper - 8. Covered every blade of grass by 60 min mark. Lovely first-time toe poke pass to Knocky in second half.

Groß - 8. What an engine. Always provided options and distributed the ball. Couple of lovely crosses. His Cruyf turns are simply majestic!

March - 5. I think the big occasion got to him. Went missing. Should have wellied the ball out for the corner which led to their goal.

Murray - 7. Always provided an outlet. Bullied the United centre-backs. Unlucky not to get on the end of a couple of crosses.

Subs
Izquierdo - 6. Offered much more than March. Used his pace to stretch United.
Hemed - 5. Hardly got into game. Couple of flicks.
Brown - N/A. Maybe should have come on early for Propper, as Davy looked drainer around 75 mins.

Fans: 9. Sang for the whole 90mins.
Chant of the afternoon ‘We support our local team’ aimed at all the day trippers from Sweden and Holland.

Pretty much nailed it there. Completely agree that March was really the only player that looked a bit overawed by the occasion. The rest were fantastic. Despite the defeat hopefully a further confidence-boost for the squad that they belong at this level.

How can 72000 ‘fans’ make so little noise ?

Whitechapel · Nov 25, 2017

Nixonator said:
Comparing it to homophobic chants and implied bestiality... ok.

I was comparing it in terms of originality to the homophobic chants we receive which I even pointed out at the bottom of my post. I should have realised there would still be some dickhead who try and make out that I was giving a direct comparison between the two chants though. Congratulations on winning the "f*ck me NSC is predictable" award for today.

Nixonator said:
First of all we weren’t being directly offensive (heaven ****ing forbid) and is simply a statement of truth, with implication that it isn’t true for large part of the other 67k present, which is also undoubtedly accurate.

I never claimed we were being offensive, just pointing out that Manchester United have probably heard the same song from almost every single set of fans for the last 20-30 years. "It was a simple statement of truth". Well... unless the person singing it was from the north of our catchment area (Haywards Heath, Horsham, Tunbridge Wells, East Grinstead as their local team would be Crawley) or if they were from extreme west of our catchment area (Bognor/Chichester as their local team would be Portsmouth)

Also, the implication of it not being true for the other 67k is by no means 'undoubtedly accurate'. Despite them having a lot of fans across the country, and indeed the globe most Manchester United season tickets are actually from, shock horror Manchester and the surrounding areas. I dislike armchair Manchester United fans as much as anyone else, but acting holier than thou to fans who have actually made the effort to get to OT? Just seems like a weird thing to label as "chant of the day." It's the kind of thing you'd expect a League One team to sing if they drew a big team in the F.A cup.

Not trying to take anything away from our fans, they were by-and-large excellent today, just thought such an unimaginative, shitty song was a weird thing to pull up as a highlight.

Nixonator said:
You must be a right laugh.

Thanks, I'd like to say the same back, but I can't.

Buzzer said:
Utter rubbish.

Thank you for your well explained counter points which really added to the conversation. They really have helped me see the situation from your point of view. Top work.

Pevenseagull · Nov 26, 2017

I haven't seen anything, but I think Davy P was the bestest.

Nixonator · Nov 26, 2017

Whitechapel said:
Just seems like a weird thing to label as "chant of the day." It's the kind of thing you'd expect a League One team to sing if they drew a big team in the F.A cup.

I didn't label it as 'chant of the day', I disagreed with you labelling it as tired and predictable.

Trigger · Nov 26, 2017

Ryan 7
Bruno 7
Duffy 7
Dunk 8
Bong 8
Knockaert 7
Pröpper 7
Stephens 7
March 6
Groß 8
Murray 9

Izquierdo 6
Hemed 6
Brown 6

Neville's Breakfast · Nov 26, 2017

Whitechapel said:
Really?

It's about as boring and predictable as "Sheepshaggers" against Cardiff/Swansea or the general homophobic crap we get*.One of those where the fans of the team you sung it against probably rolled there eyes and muttered about how original it was. Would have genuinely been more impressed if our fans hadn't sunk to the levels of such boring, predictable shit but each to their own.

*I'm not saying that it is as offensive as homophobic chant, merely pointing out how unoriginal and boring it is.

Maybe you’re taking it a bit too seriously. It’s a football match not University Challenge.

Blue3 · Nov 26, 2017

Petee said:
Ryan 7
Bruno 8 MOTM
Duffy 8
Dunk 8
Bong 8
Knockaert 7.5
Propper 7.5
Stephens 7.5
March 6
Groß 8
Murray 7.5

Izquierdo 6
Hemed 6
Brown NA

Cannot disagree with you view of the game back four were outstanding

chimneys · Nov 26, 2017

Whitechapel said:
I was comparing it in terms of originality to the homophobic chants we receive which I even pointed out at the bottom of my post. I should have realised there would still be some dickhead who try and make out that I was giving a direct comparison between the two chants though. Congratulations on winning the "f*ck me NSC is predictable" award for today.

I never claimed we were being offensive, just pointing out that Manchester United have probably heard the same song from almost every single set of fans for the last 20-30 years. "It was a simple statement of truth". Well... unless the person singing it was from the north of our catchment area (Haywards Heath, Horsham, Tunbridge Wells, East Grinstead as their local team would be Crawley) or if they were from extreme west of our catchment area (Bognor/Chichester as their local team would be Portsmouth)

Also, the implication of it not being true for the other 67k is by no means 'undoubtedly accurate'. Despite them having a lot of fans across the country, and indeed the globe most Manchester United season tickets are actually from, shock horror Manchester and the surrounding areas. I dislike armchair Manchester United fans as much as anyone else, but acting holier than thou to fans who have actually made the effort to get to OT? Just seems like a weird thing to label as "chant of the day." It's the kind of thing you'd expect a League One team to sing if they drew a big team in the F.A cup.

Not trying to take anything away from our fans, they were by-and-large excellent today, just thought such an unimaginative, shitty song was a weird thing to pull up as a highlight.

Thanks, I'd like to say the same back, but I can't.

Thank you for your well explained counter points which really added to the conversation. They really have helped me see the situation from your point of view. Top work.

For someone to care as much as you clearly do, am guessing you are closet United? Half and half scarf already on your wall?

Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊

[Albion] Player ratings v Man Utd (a)

New member

Member

Well-known member

New member

Famous Last Words

Active member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Languidly Clinical

Well-known member

Famous Last Words

Anti-greed coalition

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Share this page