When will we learn

pottert · Sep 21, 2016

Last season we put out a crap team against Walsall we lost & they played Chelsea in the next round.
This season we put out a crap team against Reading we lose & they get a trip to the Emirates in the next round.
What confuses the hell out of me is.
It's common knowledge that we lose millions of pounds every season playing in the championship.
So why are we not playing full strength teams
In these cup competions.
Not only do you give yourselves a better chance of winning each game so you can get that plum tie in the next round but the fans will be more likely to turn up against the lesser teams knowing
That you are playing your strongest possible team.6000 in the 3rd round of the league cup is
A disgrace.

Of course if we had played our strongest team against Reading there are no guarantees that we would have won as there are no guarantees that we will win against Barnsley on Saturday having rested 11 players.

MattBackHome · Sep 21, 2016

If we had won then we would have drawn Hull away.

Thunder Bolt · Sep 21, 2016

MattBackHome said:
If we had won then we would have drawn Hull away.

This. We would have been a different number in the draw.

Da Man Clay · Sep 21, 2016

Because the league cup is worth so little in comparison to the PL. imagine the stick on here if we'd started Kayal, Stephens and Dunk and they were all crocked and out for months. Basically written off any chance to be promoted. I've no interest in going to a 1/2 full Emirates to play their kids.

Bry Nylon · Sep 21, 2016

pottert said:
Last season we put out a crap team against Walsall we lost & they played Chelsea in the next round.
This season we put out a crap team against Reading we lose & they get a trip to the Emirates in the next round.
What confuses the hell out of me is.
It's common knowledge that we lose millions of pounds every season playing in the championship.
So why are we not playing full strength teams
In these cup competions.
Not only do you give yourselves a better chance of winning each game so you can get that plum tie in the next round but the fans will be more likely to turn up against the lesser teams knowing
That you are playing your strongest possible team.6000 in the 3rd round of the league cup is
A disgrace.

I've read better poems, to be fair.

beorhthelm · Sep 21, 2016

put out strongest team, pick up some injuries, lose and carry that into the next league game... League cup doesnt matter and going another round or two isnt going to save the finances, use it for trialing fringe and development squad, just like the big clubs do.

Return of the Rev · Sep 21, 2016

Thunder Bolt said:
This. We would have been a different number in the draw.

man city at home?

Thunder Bolt · Sep 21, 2016

Return of the Rev said:
man city at home?

Hull away.

Mackenzie · Sep 21, 2016

One less distraction for us and one huge distraction for an improving Reading. OK it's crap for us supporters (Hull away would have been AMAZING) but hopefully will benefit us in the long run.

Gabbafella · Sep 21, 2016

The league is priority and our best players need to be fit enough all season to get us promoted. The cup is an unnecessary distraction, especially this early in the season.
I'm sure I'm not alone when I say that the cup doesn't interest me, climbing the table does.

Bry Nylon · Sep 21, 2016

The League Cup has become a joke and needs some sort of overhaul if it is going to survive beyond the next 5 years.

Maybe it should be re-invented and clubs are only allowed to field domestic players (English, Scots, Welsh or N Irish). It might not increase gates but at least it would make it a bit different.

pottert · Sep 21, 2016

beorhthelm said:
put out strongest team, pick up some injuries, lose and carry that into the next league game... League cup doesnt matter and going another round or two isnt going to save the finances, use it for trialing fringe and development squad, just like the big clubs do.

So if we had won & got a big home draw would we still be making 11 changes to the starting line up.

I understand that some players may need a rest but this is a major cup game.
We had a bigger crowd for the 1st round against Colchester than the 3rd round against Reading.

Steve in Japan · Sep 21, 2016

I can't be arsed with the League Cup, but have more time for the FA Cup (which I am sure we will treat in the same indifferent way). I would prefer us to take the Cups seriously but realistically it's not going to happen. It's not just Brighton, all clubs in the top 2 divisions at least treat cup ties as a diversion, a chance to rotate the squad.

I don't like it but it's now standard practice.

rocker959 · Sep 21, 2016

So glad I was around when the League and FA Cups both really mattered . First Division (Premier )clubs fielding their strongest team as did we. Great memories of great games. Wolves at home in 1969 , North Stand goal net strewn with toilet rolls , 32000 plus gate . Also R1 Ipswich won 27,000 gate , WestBrom (a) , then Derby home 33000 and away replay taking 7000 fans in Wardys era .The days when clubs wished to win every cup and league game they played and clubs were fined etc for fielding under strength sides. Stuff the fans nowadays. Wish I had access to a Time Machine.

studio150 · Sep 21, 2016

yes lets forget about the league and focus on the cup competitions, as we may get a 'big' team in the draw, so that all those once a season fans can scramble for a ticket whilst shouting how they've supported the team all their lives and its not fair that they've missed out on this 'big' game.
During this cup run we get shown on TV a few times to gain some additional income but our league form falls away and the home attendances for league games drops off as we are lower mid table flirting with relegation. We struggle to get our transfer targets as we are not seen as a team challenging for promotion to the Premier League.
Come on get working on those tin foil cups

pottert · Sep 21, 2016

Maybe it's me but I think it's currently a championship problem.Premier league teams seem to take it more seriously now than they did a few years ago probably thinking its a good chance of winning a trophy.using this week as an example most EPL teams that have played this week have played very strong teams & have been well supported.West Ham had 39000 for a game against Accrington Stanley.
Teams in league 1 & 2 take every game as a bonus.
Championship teams seem to take every game as an excuse to rotate their squad because the league is more important.
Unless they get a big draw

wakeytom · Sep 21, 2016

studio150 said:
yes lets forget about the league and focus on the cup competitions, as we may get a 'big' team in the draw, so that all those once a season fans can scramble for a ticket whilst shouting how they've supported the team all their lives and its not fair that they've missed out on this 'big' game.
During this cup run we get shown on TV a few times to gain some additional income but our league form falls away and the home attendances for league games drops off as we are lower mid table flirting with relegation. We struggle to get our transfer targets as we are not seen as a team challenging for promotion to the Premier League.
Come on get working on those tin foil cups

Just focus on those play offs every season to try and get to the holy grail. Much better than a once in a lifetime watching your team win a cup. I think you will find many premier league teams take it seriously, yes they may play a team where players are a little deeper from the squad however the team on the field will still be paid much more than any championship side

studio150 · Sep 21, 2016

wakeytom said:
Just focus on those play offs every season to try and get to the holy grail.

I hate the play-off, we should be looking to gain promotion as champions

El Presidente · Sep 21, 2016

Da Man Clay said:
Because the league cup is worth so little in comparison to the PL. imagine the stick on here if we'd started Kayal, Stephens and Dunk and they were all crocked and out for months. Basically written off any chance to be promoted. I've no interest in going to a 1/2 full Emirates to play their kids.

Very harsh. What about the opportunity to buy a half and half scarf and have a selfie taken at the Emirates?

pottert · Sep 22, 2016

wakeytom said:
Just focus on those play offs every season to try and get to the holy grail. Much better than a once in a lifetime watching your team win a cup. I think you will find many premier league teams take it seriously, yes they may play a team where players are a little deeper from the squad however the team on the field will still be paid much more than any championship side

Maybe a good cup run will be the difference between Alex Pritchard not turning around on the M25

Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊

When will we learn

New member

Well-known member

Silly old bat

T'Blades

Test your smoke alarm

A. Virgo, Football Genius

Well-known member

Silly old bat

Old Brightonian

Well-known member

Test your smoke alarm

New member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

New member

New member

Well-known member

The ONLY Gay in Brighton

New member

Share this page