Reading v Brighton 'Penalties'

T

T.G

Well-known member

Mar 30, 2011

620

Shoreham-by-Sea

• Aug 21, 2016

• #1

I thought we could of had s penalty in the second half when Knockert? Was bundled to the ground. I also thought Reading's free kick on the edge of the area was actually a penalty. It was a long way away but their players were pointing to marks in the area. Did any see the incidents or reviewed them on the tellybox?

 

spence

British and Proud

Oct 15, 2014

9,814

Crawley

• Aug 21, 2016

• #2

On the highlights the Bong challenge was bloody tight. Could have gone either way but i think the ref called it right.

Baldock is the other one you are referring to in the 2nd half. Never a pen and to lightweight. Went down to easily. Ref again right

Shame he didn't give a straight red for that scything challenge .


Like the pen Murray won against Rotherham. For me that was outside the box and he dived once inside. Ref got that call wrong

 

E

Eric Youngs Contact Lense

Guest

• Aug 21, 2016

• #3

Bong one was very tight and my immediate reaction was "penalty", and highlights suggest it could easily have been given. Baldock incident immediate reaction was "no penalty". The highlights do show defender was stronger but his foot does come across Baldock, so can understand why Baldock appealed.. That said would have felt very hard done by bad that been given against us. I the whole thought ref was ok apart from inconsistency on pushes in the back..

 

T

Telford Seagull

Well-known member

Jul 5, 2011

1,000

Telford

• Aug 21, 2016

• #4

I actually thought we should have had one early on, right side of the box as we were attacking (left for them). The ball looped up, Murray got the wrong side of Van der Berg who just went straight through the back of him. Amazed that he got away with that one, stonewall penalty.

 

Seagull58

In the Algarve

Jan 31, 2012

7,246

Vilamoura, Portugal

• Aug 21, 2016

• #5

T.G said:

I thought we could of had s penalty in the second half when Knockert? Was bundled to the ground. I also thought Reading's free kick on the edge of the area was actually a penalty. It was a long way away but their players were pointing to marks in the area. Did any see the incidents or reviewed them on the tellybox?

Click to expand...

Could HAVE

 

Thunder Bolt

Silly old bat

Aug 18, 2009

65,439

Beside the seaside, beside the sea

• Aug 21, 2016

• #6

Bong

[tweet]767399227383099392[/tweet]