5 worst players of the Amex era

Chinman3000

Well-known member

Sep 28, 2011

1,267

• Jan 7, 2016

• #1

Prompted by something said on the Gardner thread - what are peoples 5 worst players of the Amex era?

Rules - List in order of shiteness (1 most 5 least), first team players only and NO current squad players (as if you would....)

Mine;

1 - Leon Best
2 - Gary Gardner
3 - Ryan Harley
4 - Jon Obika
5 - Keith Andrews

 

T

TomandJerry

Well-known member

Oct 1, 2013

11,437

• Jan 7, 2016

• #2

Buckley, Best, Obika, Chickson and Harley

 

Sheebo

Well-known member

Jul 13, 2003

29,287

• Jan 7, 2016

• #3

Andrews is v harsh - he was OK. You seem to have missed Billy Paynter off the list! I'm sure there are others I've probably forgotten about...

 

T

turienzo's lovechild

New member

Oct 25, 2003

23,964

• Jan 7, 2016

• #4

1-4 are all great candidates but I think you're being harsh on Andrews who was a pretty effective (if incredibly boring) defensive midfielder

i'll have a think and come up with my 5

 

BUTTERBALL

East Stand Brighton Boyz

Jul 31, 2003

10,255

location location

• Jan 7, 2016

• #5

I'd take off Keith Andrews from the opening list and replace with Billy Paynter then we are probably there or thereabouts.

 

Sheebo

Well-known member

Jul 13, 2003

29,287

• Jan 7, 2016

• #6

TomandJerry said:

Buckley, Best, Obika, Chickson and Harley

Click to expand...

Buckley..?! We're all allowed opinions, of course, but in this instance yours is incredibly wrong

 

TWOCHOICEStom

Well-known member

Sep 22, 2007

10,553

Brighton

• Jan 7, 2016

• #7

TomandJerry said:

Buckley, Best, Obika, Chickson and Harley

Click to expand...

behave yourself.

Obika
Paynter

I think lumping anyone else in with these two is very harsh.

 

Sheebo

Well-known member

Jul 13, 2003

29,287

• Jan 7, 2016

• #8

sheebo said:

Andrews is v harsh - he was OK. You seem to have missed Billy Paynter off the list! I'm sure there are others I've probably forgotten about...

Click to expand...

BUTTERBALL said:

I'd take off Keith Andrews from the opening list and replace with Billy Paynter then we are probably there or thereabouts.

Click to expand...

Great minds

 

hans kraay fan club

The voice of reason.

Helpful Moderator

Mar 16, 2005

61,256

Chandlers Ford

• Jan 7, 2016

• #9

1. Leon Best
2. Jon Obika
3. David Rodrigues
4. David Gonzales
5. Gary Gardner

 

P

pishhead

Well-known member

Jul 9, 2003

5,246

Everywhere

• Jan 7, 2016

• #10

Best
Harley
Paynter
Obika
The goalie we had from Man City

 

T

TomandJerry

Well-known member

Oct 1, 2013

11,437

• Jan 7, 2016

• #11

TWOCHOICEStom said:

behave yourself.

Obika
Paynter

I think lumping anyone else in with these two is very harsh.

Click to expand...

I'd say Best should be lumped in with them two

 

Hugo Rune

Well-known member

NSC Patron

Feb 23, 2012

21,606

Brighton

• Jan 7, 2016

• #12

The worst I've seen is Shamir Fenelon by a distance. Looked so off the pace and ability level required for professional football. Not his fault though - a Burke-Hyypia blunder.

 

RandyWanger

Je suis rôti de boeuf

Mar 14, 2013

6,028

Done a Frexit, now in London

• Jan 7, 2016

• #13

Can Kemy be counted as a player?

 

BBassic

I changed this.

Jul 28, 2011

12,304

• Jan 7, 2016

• #14

Does Kemy count? Considering he didn't actually play that much?

 

T

turienzo's lovechild

New member

Oct 25, 2003

23,964

• Jan 7, 2016

• #15

-Leon Best
-Ryan Harley
-Billy Paynter
-Gary Gardner
-Kemy Agustein

we've then had a series of underwhelming products from the development squad like chicksen, adgestien, rogers, fenelon, barker to name a few but that was more to do with the gap between developmental and championship football being a bit too large rather than the other five who were just shit

 

BBassic

I changed this.

Jul 28, 2011

12,304

• Jan 7, 2016

• #16

RandyWanger said:

Can Kemy be counted as a player?

Click to expand...

Damn! Beat me to it!

 

hans kraay fan club

The voice of reason.

Helpful Moderator

Mar 16, 2005

61,256

Chandlers Ford

• Jan 7, 2016

• #17

BBassic said:

Does Kemy count? Considering he didn't actually play that much?

Click to expand...

I know he must have 'played' other times, but the only time I can recall, was a third round FA Cup win over Reading. He actually played OKAY.

 

T

turienzo's lovechild

New member

Oct 25, 2003

23,964

• Jan 7, 2016

• #18

pishhead said:

The goalie we had from Man City

Click to expand...

who was that?1

 

Marshy

Well-known member

Jul 6, 2003

19,716

FRUIT OF THE BLOOM

• Jan 7, 2016

• #19

1. Paynter
2. Obika
3. Best
4. Rodriguez..
5.Lita
6.Fenelon
7. Dobbie

 

Last edited: Jan 7, 2016

JOLovegrove

Well-known member

Jan 30, 2012

2,000

• Jan 7, 2016

• #20

How anyone can even consider Keith Andrews is beyond me. Was never gonna be a player which got everyone off their seat but did his job in a successful side. And he scored a couple of goals if I'm not mistaken. And Buckley?!