Greer, Goldson, Dunk - two from three

deletebeepbeepbeep

Well-known member

May 12, 2009

20,983

• Dec 31, 2015

• #21

Green and Dunk.

Goldson will get his chance in the cup.

 

S

SockMonster

Well-known member

Oct 12, 2007

802

Brighton

• Dec 31, 2015

• #22

Greer and Dunk for me. They are still first choice for my money irrespective of Dunk's mistake. Now is the time to stick by Dunk not drop him.

 

L

London Irish

Well-known member

Nov 25, 2003

22,000

Trapped inside the Project for the New American Ce

• Dec 31, 2015

• #23

Dale Jasper said:

Who would you go for if Greer has recovered ? Goldson and Greer for me

Click to expand...

I know this is a popular choice after Dunk's awful first half performance.

But I think we need to analyse Wolves' aerial threat - if they have a good set piece record I think it's still safer to go with Dunk. He had a very decent second half against Ipswich

 

hans kraay fan club

The voice of reason.

Helpful Moderator

Mar 16, 2005

61,514

Chandlers Ford

• Dec 31, 2015

• #24

London Irish said:

I know this is a popular choice after Dunk's awful first half performance.

But I think we need to analyse Wolves' aerial threat - if they have a good set piece record I think it's still safer to go with Dunk. He had a very decent second half against Ipswich

Click to expand...

Goldson and Dunk on that basis then?

 

D

dangull

Well-known member

Feb 24, 2013

5,118

• Dec 31, 2015

• #25

When Uwe is back there will be 4 to choose from. A nice probem for a change if there is no further injuries.

 

K

Kneon Light

Well-known member

Jul 24, 2003

1,818

Falkland Islands

• Dec 31, 2015

• #26

Greer and Goldson for me.

Not just 1 mistake from Dunk - has made far too many this season. Great player at his best but needs to learn to concentrate for 90 minutes without moments of idiocy. Also having waited for his chance I don't think it would be right to drop Goldson after he grabbed it with both hands.

 

nwgull

Well-known member

Jul 25, 2003

13,861

Manchester

• Dec 31, 2015

• #27

Goldson and Dunk. Dunk was our player of the season last year and is probably the most talented defender we have. All players make errors; they just seem to be more noticeable when it's a centre half or keeper.

 

Withdean11

Well-known member

Feb 18, 2007

2,789

Brighton/Hyde

• Dec 31, 2015

• #28

Greer and Goldson.

Can not believe people are still knocking Greer. Last time he was out, it was clear we missed him and our defence largely improved upon his return. Dunk is a liability and if Uwe was fit I wouldn't even have him in the squad. 4th choice in my eyes.

 

Stumpy Tim

Well-known member

Jul 6, 2003

14,038

Back in Brighton. Well Hove actually

• Dec 31, 2015

• #29

Dunk is both our best defender and our worst. But, the only way for him to learn to eliminate the brain-farts is to play. For me, Dunk and Greer is the right choice but Uwe and Goldson are both excellent back-ups.

 

H

Hampster Gull

New member

Dec 22, 2010

13,462

• Dec 31, 2015

• #30

Greer Goldson for this match

 

Bob!

Coffee Buyer

Jul 5, 2003

11,156

• Dec 31, 2015

• #31

It sounds to me like Greers fitness is still doubtful for tomorrow. I say give him a rest, it's not worth jeopardising the rest of the season for a game against Wolves.
Stick with Dunk and Goldson to hopefully give them both some confidence.

 

Blue3

Well-known member

Jan 27, 2014

5,594

Lancing

• Dec 31, 2015

• #32

Start with all three