[Albion] Should Murphy's "goal" have stood?

Bozza · Dec 30, 2015

sussex_guy2k2 · Dec 30, 2015

What do you think?

Cold Gettin Dumb · Dec 30, 2015

Not off side

StonehamPark · Dec 30, 2015

Murphy is just under 1 yard on I reckon.

8ace · Dec 30, 2015

Yes. I couldn't understand how it was disallowed at the time.

Dick Head · Dec 30, 2015

Watching on the radio he was clearly onside.

JC Footy Genius · Dec 30, 2015

Coulda, Woulda, Shoulda :shrug:

Simster · Dec 30, 2015

At best, he's clearly on-side. At worst, it is a paper thin margin but isn't the benefit of doubt supposed to go with the attacker.

So a sh!t decision has cost us a point it seems.

skipper734 · Dec 30, 2015

In an interview after the game the official concerned, admitted to a forthcoming appointment with Specsavers.

Guinness Boy · Dec 30, 2015

Onside. I was certain it was a goal at the time then doubted myself later due to the amount of ale I'd had and people near me not celebrating or cutting off their cheer quickly.

DanRedman · Dec 30, 2015

I can understand why the lino gave it offside, he only gets one chance and it was incredibly tight. Just another call for video technology to help assist the referees...

essbee · Dec 30, 2015

Time we stopped relying on f****** cretin linos to make decisions. Get some technology in.

The Birdman · Dec 30, 2015

I think if we had scored at that stage I think we had a very good chance of going on to win the game I normally except that you win some and lose some calls but this one could prove very costly. Maybe it's time for some technology to be used in limited situations but we could open a can of worms.

BBassic · Dec 30, 2015

Absolutely 100% onside.

I'm in WSU more or less on the goal line. I am baffled at how a lino mere yards away could have gotten it wrong.

I say this every season it seems but there has to be some sort of recourse for poor officiating. As it is, they have shockers and are then back on the pitch the following week. It doesn't help with the loss of points but maybe if they started getting some sort of punitive action for being **** they'd stop being so GOD-DAMN ****.

BensGrandad · Dec 30, 2015

From the still photograph posted by Bozza I would say he looks to be offside, which I thought at the time, but if anybody has a video of it we may get a better view. It was a 50/50 decision and could have one either way.

Guinness Boy · Dec 30, 2015

BensGrandad said:
From the still photograph posted by Bozza I would say he looks to be offside, which I thought at the time, but if anybody has a video of it we may get a better view. It was a 50/50 decision and could have one either way.

If only there were some sort of handy online video. Oh wait....

http://www.skysports.com/football/brighton-vs-ipswich/339809

Not only was he onside, the left back holds up the hand of apology to his team mates.

#TheGrandadParodyAcoountContinues

Sheebo · Dec 30, 2015

All the officials were shocking all night. The North end Lino both halves seemed to not understand the offside rule. There was another where Murphy was put through on the halfway line and seemed to time the run perfectly. But too perfectly as the poor official lazily raised his flag once he'd seen Murphy running about 5 yards ahead of the defenders. Obviously I'd need a replay but it looked on. Again.

Sheebo · Dec 30, 2015

BensGrandad said:
From the still photograph posted by Bozza I would say he looks to be offside, which I thought at the time, but if anybody has a video of it we may get a better view. It was a 50/50 decision and could have one either way.

I just looked at the vote and thought 'how the hell could 3 people call that offside - must be the palace sad trolls.' Then read your post and remembered your account :thumbsup:

wellquickwoody · Dec 30, 2015

I try to think on the basis that these things even themselves out over a season to a large degree.

When, not if, soccerball moves to fourth officials and Hawkeye technology then a lot of the pleasure of watching will be removed as talking points will no longer exist, along with threads like this.

But the goal should have stood as it was not offside, but.............meh :shrug:

essbee · Dec 30, 2015

And do you reckon the linos ever review their decisions in the vain hope that the f*****s might
learn from their mistakes? My guess is that they go back to their day jobs where everyone hates them
because they are usually power hungry a**holes and forget about it until the next match where
they screw up again and again and again.

Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊

[Albion] Should Murphy's "goal" have stood?

Should Murphy's "goal" have stood?

Yes - the player wide right was playing him onside

No - he was offside

You can change this

Well-known member

Active member

#Brighton-Nil

Banned

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

Bringer of TRUTH

"the man's an arse"

Registered ruffian

Tofu eating wokerati

Active member

New member

New member

I changed this.

New member

Tofu eating wokerati

Well-known member

Well-known member

Many More Voting Years

New member

Share this page