Page 1 of 4 1234 LastLast
Results 1 to 10 of 32
  1. #1
    Members
    Join Date
    Jul 2003
    Posts
    6,659

    Player ratings vs Huddersfield


    0 Not allowed!
    Probably one of the very worst Albion performances I have ever seen. No skill, no ability, no passion, no goals. A complete and utter embarrassment.

    Stockdale 6. Did what he needed to OK.
    Bruno 3. Mostly bad with the odd flash of OK. Still unable to pass the ball forward.
    Dunk 5. Way off his best, but we kept a clean sheet.
    Halford 6. Poorest I have seen from him. Almost contrived to gift them a goal in the second half, but apart from that our best defender.
    Bennett 4. His performances are going downhill fast. Definitely not what we need at LB next season.
    Kayal 5. Not up to his recent standard.
    Stephens 4. Didn't contribute enough. Too many misplaced passes.
    Calderon 3. Didn't realise he was on the pitch most of the time.
    Tex 6. Our only creative player. Stupid and unnecessary tackle to get himself injured.
    Carayol 5. Looked like he may be a decent footballer.
    Best 3. Not the worst game he has had for us ... but that's not saying much.

    Subs:
    Lua Lua 4. Didn't see enough of the ball. no-impact sub.
    CMS 4. Not the answer when we need a goal.
    O'Grady 4. Poorest I have seen from him.

    Manager 3. He is quickly losing my support. If this is the type of football he serves up, then we have progressed absolutely nowhere.

    • North Stand Chat

      advertising
      Join Date: Jul 2003
      Posts: Lots

        


    • #2
      Falmer here we come
      Join Date
      Jan 2008
      Posts
      1,207


      0 Not allowed!
      Quote Originally Posted by goldstone View Post
      This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote
      Probably one of the very worst Albion performances I have ever seen. No skill, no ability, no passion, no goals. A complete and utter embarrassment.

      Stockdale 6. Did what he needed to OK.
      Bruno 3. Mostly bad with the odd flash of OK. Still unable to pass the ball forward.
      Dunk 5. Way off his best, but we kept a clean sheet.
      Halford 6. Poorest I have seen from him. Almost contrived to gift them a goal in the second half, but apart from that our best defender.
      Bennett 4. His performances are going downhill fast. Definitely not what we need at LB next season.
      Kayal 5. Not up to his recent standard.
      Stephens 4. Didn't contribute enough. Too many misplaced passes.
      Calderon 3. Didn't realise he was on the pitch most of the time.
      Tex 6. Our only creative player. Stupid and unnecessary tackle to get himself injured.
      Carayol 5. Looked like he may be a decent footballer.
      Best 3. Not the worst game he has had for us ... but that's not saying much.

      Subs:
      Lua Lua 4. Didn't see enough of the ball. no-impact sub.
      CMS 4. Not the answer when we need a goal.
      O'Grady 4. Poorest I have seen from him.

      Manager 3. He is quickly losing my support. If this is the type of football he serves up, then we have progressed absolutely nowhere.
      This about sums it up, but would knock a point off everyone and increase Best to a 5 because I thought he did show a shit in the first half, which is more than most. Out of order booing him off, because he definitely wasn't the worst player out there.
    • #3
      Members
      Join Date
      Aug 2006
      Location
      Worthing
      Posts
      13,640


      0 Not allowed!
      Stockdale - 7
      Bruno - 5
      Bennett - 6
      Dunk - 5
      Halford - 5
      Calderon - 4 - probably played himself out of a contract in the last 2 games
      Kayal - 7
      Stephens - 5 - worst performance since he returned
      Texeirra - 5.5 - sorry he was injured, but ran around in circles creating very little.
      Carayol - 5 - not fit
      Best - 4.5 - thought he was better than against Bournemouth, but his awareness and movement are truly woeful.

      KLL - 5
      CMS - 5
      O'Grady - 5
    • #4
      Members PILTDOWN MAN's Avatar
      Join Date
      Sep 2004
      Location
      on the street
      Posts
      10,288


      0 Not allowed!
      Stockdale 5 MOM
      Bruno 2 Awful even managed to F**k up his only trick tonight.
      Dunk 2 Awful
      Halford 2 Awful
      Bennett 2 Awful
      Kayal 4 Slightly better than awful
      Stephens 4 Slightly better than awful but does a very crap Keith Lemon impression.
      Calderon 3 Being 2015 years old is showing.
      Tex 0 Caused his own downfall with a shocking challenge.
      Crayon 2 Started Ok but suddenly became crap and then out down that by getting worse
      Best 0 Gone past his best before date.


      Lua Lua 0 crap
      O Grady 0 crap
      Labrador 0 crap

      Hooton 0
      “FROM the towns all Inns have been driven: from the villages most. . . . Change your hearts or you will lose your Inns and you will deserve to have lost them. But when you have lost your Inns drown your empty selves, for you will have lost the last of England.”
    • #5

      0 Not allowed!
      Quote Originally Posted by goldstone View Post
      This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote
      Probably one of the very worst Albion performances I have ever seen. No skill, no ability, no passion, no goals. A complete and utter embarrassment.

      Stockdale 6. Did what he needed to OK.
      Bruno 3. Mostly bad with the odd flash of OK. Still unable to pass the ball forward.
      Dunk 5. Way off his best, but we kept a clean sheet.
      Halford 6. Poorest I have seen from him. Almost contrived to gift them a goal in the second half, but apart from that our best defender.
      Bennett 4. His performances are going downhill fast. Definitely not what we need at LB next season.
      Kayal 5. Not up to his recent standard.
      Stephens 4. Didn't contribute enough. Too many misplaced passes.
      Calderon 3. Didn't realise he was on the pitch most of the time.
      Tex 6. Our only creative player. Stupid and unnecessary tackle to get himself injured.
      Carayol 5. Looked like he may be a decent footballer.
      Best 3. Not the worst game he has had for us ... but that's not saying much.

      Subs:
      Lua Lua 4. Didn't see enough of the ball. no-impact sub.
      CMS 4. Not the answer when we need a goal.
      O'Grady 4. Poorest I have seen from him.

      Manager 3. He is quickly losing my support. If this is the type of football he serves up, then we have progressed absolutely nowhere.
      I agree with all, but Carayol 5?! You're joking right? He hit the bar, that was it! His movement is appalling
    • #6

      0 Not allowed!
      Does anyone actually believe any of them deserve a rating?

      How come Hughton is not on the list?
    • #7
      Members
      Join Date
      Jul 2003
      Location
      Uffern
      Posts
      26,743


      1 Not allowed!
      Too depressing to rate them (and if I did, I'd have to give Calde a low mark and I couldn't bring myself to do it). Thought Stockdale and Kayal were the only players who could hold their heads up tonight, although Stephens wasn't too bad. Reckoned Best was slightly better than against Bournemouth but can't see what Carayol brings to the team - no ball control and no pace, not exactly what you want in a winger
    • #8
      Devil's Advocate (p/t)
      Join Date
      Nov 2008
      Location
      Brighton
      Posts
      27,263


      0 Not allowed!
      Stockdale - 6 Not really tested.
      Bruno - 5 So nearly scored with a miss hit cross.
      Halford - 5
      Dunk - 5
      Bennett - 5
      Calderon - 4.5
      Kayal - 5
      Stephens - 5.5
      Teixeira - 5.5 Might be higher if he dared to shoot more often, or showed some awareness of passing options
      Best - 4.5 What was he thinking with that dive?
      Carayol - 5 I think there's a decent footballer in there, but I'm not sure we'll see it, he is still trying to get up to full match fitness after a long lay off, is also trying to get used to a new team and new system, and is doing this in the middle of a relegation assault course net (it doesn't really feel like a dog fight, and we seem to be slowly escaping relegation as the teams behind us get trapped)

      Lualua - 4 He seems as scared of running at opponents as Teixeira is of shooting
      CMS - 4 Didn't do anything of note after coming on
      O'Grady - 4


      It is now (including injury time) 9 hours 56 minutes since a Brighton player scored.
      Please report offensive or libellous posts - read more
    • #9
      Members
      Join Date
      Dec 2013
      Posts
      529


      0 Not allowed!
      stockdale 6
      Bruno 6 ( better 2nd half)
      halford 6
      dunk 6
      Bennett 6
      Kayal 6
      Stephens 6
      Calderon 4
      tex 6(decent first half tired again b4 bad challenge)
      carayol 4
      best 4
      lualua 5
      cog 4
      CMS 3 ( wow is his confidence low the thought of trapping the ball seems to make him fall over)
      same old same old better team particularly in the first half
      lack of quality in the final third
    • #10
      Really Sayin' Somethin' Trigger's Avatar
      Join Date
      Jul 2003
      Location
      Salzburg
      Posts
      40,424


      0 Not allowed!
      Stockdale - 6
      Bruno - 4
      Halford - 4
      Dunk - 4
      Bennett - 5
      Calderon - 4
      Kayal - 5
      Stephens - 5
      Teixeira - 4
      Best - 4
      Carayol - 5

      Lualua - 5
      Mackail-Smith - 1
      O'Grady - 6

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •