[Albion] Calde and Greer

W

WeTheSouthStand

New member

Apr 6, 2013

16

Peacehaven

• Jan 25, 2015

• #1

I was at the game today and as pleasing as the performance was I couldn't help but notice we were very slow defensively. The problem for me was that Greer and Calderon are just not quick enough and often struggled to keep up with the Arsenal attack. I appreciate that Arsenal play a very fluid and quick style of football but even against Championship opponents I find myself anxious when the opposing striker runs at our defence.

Of course I, like most fans, have a lot of respect for both of them for all the hard work they have put in at the Albion but, surely it's time we found someone new?

 

W

WeTheSouthStand

New member

Apr 6, 2013

16

Peacehaven

• Jan 25, 2015

• Thread starter
• #2

Apologies, I hadn't read that before posting.

 

Mowgli37

Enigmatic Asthmatic

Jan 13, 2013

6,371

Sheffield

• Jan 25, 2015

• #3

Both had flippy floppy first halves, as did pretty much the whole team but I felt they came back really strongly in the second. I was terrified when Calde got put back to Right-back but he did a sterling job for the rest of the match.

 

Thunder Bolt

Silly old bat

Aug 18, 2009

65,481

Beside the seaside, beside the sea

• Jan 25, 2015

• #4

Plooks said:

Think before you post.

Click to expand...

This. Calde wasn't in defence, until the substitutions were made.

 

Bladders

Twats everywhere

Jun 22, 2012

13,672

The Troubadour

• Jan 26, 2015

• #5

WeTheSouthStand said:

I was at the game today and as pleasing as the performance was I couldn't help but notice we were very slow defensively. The problem for me was that Greer and Calderon are just not quick enough and often struggled to keep up with the Arsenal attack. I appreciate that Arsenal play a very fluid and quick style of football but even against Championship opponents I find myself anxious when the opposing striker runs at our defence.



Of course I, like most fans, have a lot of respect for both of them for all the hard work they have put in at the Albion but, surely it's time we found someone new?

Click to expand...

You've only just noticed?

 

W

West Hoathly Seagull

Honorary Ruffian

Aug 26, 2003

3,540

Sharpthorne/SW11

• Jan 26, 2015

• #6

Calderon was not the problem in defence today, Bennett was. If anyone was overawed by the occasion, it was him. Calde was excellent once moved into defence and just about our only attacking outlet in the first half. Regarding Greer, I've felt we needed a long-term replacement for him for some time. As others have said, he is too slow and increasingly easy for good forwards to beat, as shown by Murphy on Wednesday night.

As for Dunk, his big money move may be some while off if today's showing is anything to go by. Should have closed Ozil down for their second, and poor clearance for their third, then he and Greer stood off Rosicky. Okay, you can say he won't face that level of opposition every week, but he will in the Premiership. What was noticeable was that Greer still wouldn't pass to Calderon; on at least one occasion he passed inside, putting us in danger, when Calderon had a clear run forward.

 

Last edited: Jan 26, 2015

clungemeister

New member

Jan 11, 2015

152

• Jan 26, 2015

• #7

our defence is not a solid as two seasons ago ...dunk has not reached upson's mark and bennett is certainly no bridge , some very questionable passing going in in defence trying neat little 3m passes inside your own penalty area whilst under pressure is not a good idea against the likes of arsenal.

 

1

1234andcounting

Well-known member

Mar 31, 2008

1,609

• Jan 26, 2015

• #8

Our return match in the Champions League against Arsenal is going to be a problem, then.

Oh!

 

Behind Enemy Lines

Well-known member

Jul 18, 2003

4,805

London

• Jan 26, 2015

• #9

The defence will need a major overhaul in the summer. A permanent left-back and at least one centre-half, probably two, will be the minimum of requirements.

 

G

goldstone

Well-known member

Jul 5, 2003

7,122

• Jan 26, 2015

• #10

Certainly agree about Greer. Either Hughes or Halford would be a better partner for Dunk right now. Calderon might have another season as a squad utility player, but we do need another top class right back.

 

Mellotron

I've asked for soup

Jul 2, 2008

31,845

Brighton

• Jan 26, 2015

• #11

Greer's pace has been a big issue in a large number of the goals we've conceded in the past couple of months. Always a fan of his passing range but his pace is really starting to expose him, even at lower Championship level.

 

JBenno

New member

Jun 29, 2011

429

Upper Beeding

• Jan 26, 2015

• #12

Mellotron said:

Greer's pace has been a big issue in a large number of the goals we've conceded in the past couple of months. Always a fan of his passing range but his pace is really starting to expose him, even at lower Championship level.

Click to expand...

add that to his awful positioning and decision making and I'm afraid we have a written off defender.

For recent evidence please watch:
Goal conceded against Brentford.
First Goal conceded against Ipswich.
The second Arsenal goal last night, honestly please have a look at his position when the pass is played through to Ozil.... then make your mind up.