Statistically speaking, 2012/13 season when we finished 4th. But. Realistically speaking, it was the season Bellend Extraordinaire got us promoted from League 1. Because we excelled in the seasons immediately after. Don't get me wrong he had a good few seasons with us, but he's an immature knobhead, who happened to let CO poo on the floor. And backed Jaws during Evra-gate. That whole poo debacle is one of the reasons why we've had a managerial problem recently. Not to mention the whole "hitting the ceiling" thing.