Player Ratings - Rotherham

Skaville

Well-known member

Jun 10, 2004

10,101

Queens Park

• Oct 25, 2014

• #1

Stockdale - 7 - Made some important saves in the closing stages
Calderon - 6 - Found space on a few occaisions but not utilised as much as Bennett
Dunk - 6 - Outmuscled a bit at times but our most assured defender
Greer - 4 - Joke of a performance. Incredibly bad distribution, lost Revell for the goal
Bennett - 6 - Got a bit lucky with the goal but a good finish. Wasteful at times when well placed
Ince - 7 - Battled hard. looking a better option than Holla at the moment
JFC - 5 - Oh dear
Gardener - 4- Oh dear oh dear
Baldrick - 5 - At least he worked hard
O'Grady -3 - One of the worst centre forward displays I have ever seen andhe got 90 minutes! Hiding.
Collunga - 6 - Probably a generous rating but he looked alright at times when he came inside

McCourt - 7 - Great cameo. Liked the rollocking he gave O'Grady. Passion
Tex - 5 - Did little of note

Sami - 0 - It takes a big man to admit you are wrong. Sami, you might be a big man but teh tactis have been diabolical for weeks and your unwillingness to change them shoudl cost you your job

 

Marshy

Well-known member

Jul 6, 2003

19,724

FRUIT OF THE BLOOM

• Oct 25, 2014

• #2

Stockdale 9 several fine saves
Calderon 5
Greer 5
Dunk 6
Bennett 6

Ince 5
Gardner 5
JFC 8 very good escpecially 1st half

Colunga 7 our only forward spark
Ogrady 5
Baldock 5

 

Skaville

Well-known member

Jun 10, 2004

10,101

Queens Park

• Oct 25, 2014

• Thread starter
• #3

Mods, please merge with other thread

 

Trigger

Well-known member

Jul 4, 2003

40,457

Brighton

• Oct 25, 2014

• #4

Stockdale 7

Calderon 5
Greer 5
Dunk 6
Bennett 6

Ince 6
Gardner 5
Forster-Caskey 6

Colunga 4
O'Grady 4
Baldock 3

McCourt 6
Teixeira 5

 

sllugaes

New member

Dec 15, 2012

673

• Oct 25, 2014

• #5

Stockdale 7
Calderon 5
Greer 4
Dunk 6
Bennett 6

Ince 7
Gardner 4
JFC 6

Ogrady 5
Baldock 5
Culunga 6

Mccourt 6
Teixiera 5

Sami Have you heard of wing play!

 

sllugaes

New member

Dec 15, 2012

673

• Oct 25, 2014

• #6

Marshy said:

Stockdale 9 several fine saves
Calderon 5
Greer 5
Dunk 6
Bennett 6

Ince 5
Gardner 5
JFC 8 very good escpecially 1st half

Colunga 7 our only forward spark
Ogrady 5
Baldock 5

Click to expand...

Agree JFC good first half for what he usually gives - although really an 8. You think he played better than Ince today?

 

Tubby-McFat-Fuc

Well-known member

May 2, 2013

1,845

Brighton

• Oct 25, 2014

• #7

Stockdale - 9 - Back to his best. Head and shoulders above everyone
Calderon - 5 - I know he's a legend, he also League standard.
Dunk - 6 -
Greer - 3 - Has to be left out on that performance. Sums us up at the momentm
Bennett - 5 -
Ince - 7 -
JFC - 5 - Takes so long over everything. If he shags like he plays football, he'll have the happiest girlfriend alive.
Gardener - 3 - Waste of space. Shooting today reminded me of a park player
Baldock - 5 - Done all he could, but like CMS play to his weakness and he'll struggle.
O'Grady -1 - Lazy pointless ****. A disgrace to the game. Whoever signed that needs shooting. Slow to react, no effort, shouldn't be on a professional football pitch again. At one point I though a steward might run on and drag him off. Clearly not a footballer.
Collunga - 6 - Like Baldock and CMS, play him out of position, and he won't produce anything.


Sami - 0 - Out of his depth. How long can this go on.

 

Napier's Knee

New member

Mar 23, 2014

1,099

West Sussex

• Oct 25, 2014

• #8

Marshy said:

Stockdale 9 several fine saves
Calderon 5
Greer 5
Dunk 6
Bennett 6

Ince 5
Gardner 5
JFC 8 very good escpecially 1st half

Colunga 7 our only forward spark
Ogrady 5
Baldock 5

Click to expand...

Totally agree, but the players are doing as well as they can in an inept system. We need to blame the players less and Sami more.

 

J

J2 DOG

Active member

Feb 28, 2009

600

Hove

• Oct 25, 2014

• #9

Stockdale 7 - good saves, but still parries into dangerzones!
Calderon 6 -ok
Bennett 5 - good on the ball,strangely not that interested in defending.
Greer 5- Different player to the one that played for Scotland a fortnight ago.
Dunk 7- Class act,will be gone in January and replaced by £50,000 buy from Crawley.
JFC 6- Good first half,Whole midfield very disjointed in the 2nd.
Ince 6- Needs to look interested at times. Created little.
Gardiner- Underachieving and not at best. Shooting wasteful and piss poor!
Colunga- Some nice use of the ball,passed with conviction and didnt loose the ball as much as others.
COG- worked hard and put himself about!Should have attacked back stick when Mccourt put over good ball. Exposed at this level or in this current system??
Baldock- as above and possibly could have worked harder in the last 20 mins.


Subs. Mccourt and Teixeira
Couldnt change much but tried. Done ok. Came on to play in a crap team!
Both tried to help change the disjointed play, bad shape, no passion, low work rate. Lucky to get a point against an average side!

 

SIMMO SAYS

Well-known member

Jul 31, 2012

11,716

Incommunicado

• Oct 25, 2014

• #10

Who ever signed O grady and colunger should be shot

 

G

goldstone

Well-known member

Jul 5, 2003

7,124

• Oct 25, 2014

• #11

This is getting so so depressing.

Stockdale 7. Some very good saves. Distribution mostly OK. MoM
Calderon 5. Too often stuck upfield when he should be defending. I guess that's the system ... it stinks.
Greer 3. Worst game he's had for us.
Dunk 6. Did OK with little defensive assistance.
Bennett 6. Well taken goal after seeming to screw up the opportunity. Defensively OK. Gave us some width at times. One or two decent crosses.
Ince 5. Probably the least impressive performance I have seen from him this season. Needs to be better with his heading for a tall guy.
JFC 5. Still not impressed.
Gardner 5. Started quite brightly, but faded.
Colunga 6. Thought he had quite a good game with little support.
Baldock 5. Needs a run in the team and some support ... and as a striker how about playing him as a striker ... but I guess that's not Sami's way
COG 4. Not bad first half, but very poor 2nd.

Subs:
McCourt 7. At least he tried to make things happen. Cannot understand why he was not given longer.
Tex 6. Considering how the game was going .... nowhere ... surprised he wasn't given longer.

Manager 1. He has to go. Not all his fault, but he has to be able to do better with the players at his disposal. And the stupid system he has introduced will never work with the players we have. When will he realise this?