Was JFC’s goal at QPR unfairly disallowed?

symyjym · Sep 19, 2013

On watching the highlights I was shocked to not see any reason for Jake’s perfectly good goal to be disallowed. There was no offside and there was no infringement in our passage of play.

Just seems harsh, for all that hard work the team put in last night, we did the job and got a bad decision against us. I'm not saying we would have won but QPR would have been forced to press and would have left themselves more open to us scoring a second.

Does anyone else have a view on this disallowed goal?

Wilka · Sep 19, 2013

I think Barnes shoved someone if I recall correctly.

Stumpy Tim · Sep 19, 2013

Definite Barnes push... You could see it clearly and we were at the other end of the pitch. No arguments here

Leighgull · Sep 19, 2013

I've not seen the highlights but the ref was a disgrace so don't be too surprised.

I didn't see the Barnes shove at the time but the officials were clearly blind except on that one occasion.

symyjym · Sep 19, 2013

Stumpy Tim said:
Definite Barnes push... You could see it clearly and we were at the other end of the pitch. No arguments here

Wilka said:
I think Barnes shoved someone if I recall correctly.

I've looked at it several times on the player, and the QPR commentary on it laughed out how soft it was if anything even happened at all. The exact words were Brighton may think themselves a little unlucky to have been penalised.

Grombleton · Sep 19, 2013

Just watched the highlights on Player - definite shove by Barnes.

TheMajor · Sep 19, 2013

Leighgull said:
I've not seen the highlights but the ref was a disgrace so don't be too surprised.

I didn't see the Barnes shove at the time but the officials were clearly blind except on that one occasion.

Ref was alright. He got the big decisions right apart from when he should have booked Barton for deliberate handball that would have been his second yellow. As usual it always appears that the opposition are getting the rub of the green - but that's because we are biased.

A guy near me was constantly doing his nut at the referee , which was funny because the decisions which upset him were minor.

Stumpy Tim · Sep 19, 2013

I thought the ref started badly, but got better as the game went on. We've had lots and lots of worse refs

Leighgull · Sep 19, 2013

TheMajor said:
Ref was alright. He got the big decisions right apart from when he should have booked Barton for deliberate handball that would have been his second yellow. As usual it always appears that the opposition are getting the rub of the green - but that's because we are biased.

A guy near me was constantly doing his nut at the referee , which was funny because the decisions which upset him were minor.

That was probably me. I reckon we were at different games mate, he was pony.

supaseagull · Sep 19, 2013

Leighgull said:
I've not seen the highlights but the ref was a disgrace so don't be too surprised.

I didn't see the Barnes shove at the time but the officials were clearly blind except on that one occasion.

You mean the same ref whose brother officiated the Millwall game at the Amex? now you DO surprise me!

briref · Sep 19, 2013

TheMajor said:
Ref was alright. He got the big decisions right apart from when he should have booked Barton for deliberate handball that would have been his second yellow. As usual it always appears that the opposition are getting the rub of the green - but that's because we are biased.

A guy near me was constantly doing his nut at the referee , which was funny because the decisions which upset him were minor.

Deliberate handball is not an automating caution.

TheMajor · Sep 19, 2013

briref said:
Deliberate handball is not an automating caution.

Then he had an even better game than I thought.

Should Barton have been booked for carrying the ball, when it was an Albion goalkick, 40 yards towards the centre circle and dropping it so he could get back into position ?

briref · Sep 19, 2013

TheMajor said:
Then he had an even better game than I thought.

Should Barton have been booked for carrying the ball, when it was an Albion goalkick, 40 yards towards the centre circle and dropping it so he could get back into position ?

a case could be made for time wasting/un sporting
was Barton on the receiving end of some bad decisions - or was mark bright talking more shit

The Camel · Sep 19, 2013

The whistle went a good couple of seconds before the goal, hence some players may have stopped momentarily.

Gazwag · Sep 19, 2013

TheMajor said:
Ref was alright. He got the big decisions right apart from when he should have booked Barton for deliberate handball that would have been his second yellow. As usual it always appears that the opposition are getting the rub of the green - but that's because we are biased.

.

Really

He should have booked Barton very early when he took the ball right up the pitch, the biggest joke was when Calde was fouled in the corner by us, play on waved the ref, we took out one of their players near the centre circle and the ref played on again. And as for the lineman on the left hand side :facepalm:

he only put his flag up after Austin missed that sitter to make him feel better, if he had scored I don't think the flag would have gone up.

Carrot Cruncher · Sep 19, 2013

There was an incident in the first half where one of ours was shaping to shoot and appeared to have his legs taken away. Ref waved play on. Anyone else get a better view of it?

Thunder Bolt · Sep 19, 2013

The Camel said:
The whistle went a good couple of seconds before the goal, hence some players may have stopped momentarily.

You can hear the whistle clearly on the highlights. It was a good couple of seconds before the goal.

midnight_rendezvous · Sep 19, 2013

Didn't see anything much in it on the highlights tbh. Think we were a bit unlucky

Icy Gull · Sep 19, 2013

Carrot Cruncher said:
There was an incident in the first half where one of ours was shaping to shoot and appeared to have his legs taken away. Ref waved play on. Anyone else get a better view of it?

If that was when Andrews was pulled back just as he was shaping to shoot after a good few passes to set it up, then yes but I only heard it on Player. Commentators were 100% sure it was a free kick but it wasn't given.

If I'd still been listening on 5 live then it would probably have been a great tackle if the commentator had even seen it and wasn't looking on the floor for his stopwatch

Hamilton · Sep 19, 2013

Grombleton said:
Just watched the highlights on Player - definite shove by Barnes.

It's true. He's also responsible for Gordon Smith missing that sitter at Wembley you know.

Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊

Was JFC’s goal at QPR unfairly disallowed?

Banned

Well-known member

Well-known member

New member

Banned

Surrounded by <div>s

BHA>CPFC

Well-known member

New member

Well-known member

Active member

BHA>CPFC

Active member

Well-known member

5 millionth post poster

NHS Slave

Silly old bat

Well-known member

Back on the rollercoaster

Well-known member

Share this page