[Albion] A trophy or avoid relegation...

Tyrone Biggums

Well-known member

Jun 25, 2006

13,498

Geelong, Australia

• Aug 19, 2013

• #1

A Liverpool fan put it to me that most fans would rather win say the League Cup and get relegated than stay up and not win the Cup.

I suggested that quite a few Brighton fans would rather avoid relegation than win the cup as relegation has a far more negative effect on the club than the positive effect of winning a cup.

So I put it to you Albion fans, which would you prefer?

Poll above

 

Last edited: Aug 19, 2013

Mellotron

I've asked for soup

Jul 2, 2008

31,835

Brighton

• Aug 19, 2013

• #2

Depends on the cup and what league we're in at the time.

 

Tyrone Biggums

Well-known member

Jun 25, 2006

13,498

Geelong, Australia

• Aug 19, 2013

• Thread starter
• #3

Sorry, should have prefaced. We're in the Championship and it's the League Cup

 

Joey Jo Jo Jr. Shabadoo

Waxing chumps like candles since ‘75

Oct 4, 2003

11,055

• Aug 19, 2013

• #4

While a cup would soften the blow of relegation I'd still rather not get relegated than win the league cup and go down.

 

Mellotron

I've asked for soup

Jul 2, 2008

31,835

Brighton

• Aug 19, 2013

• #5

i.e. I'd take us winning the FA Cup and going down from League 1 to League 2, I think.

 

A

ali jenkins

Thanks to Guinness Dave

Feb 9, 2006

9,896

Southwick

• Aug 19, 2013

• #6

If it is this season then winning a cup. Quality day out at Wembly and we wouldn't be in League 1 for long.

 

Tyrone Biggums

Well-known member

Jun 25, 2006

13,498

Geelong, Australia

• Aug 19, 2013

• Thread starter
• #7

Mustafa said:

Trophy, all day long - that's the point of football isn't it? Would be remembered for the next 50 years or longer

League Cup money would more than cover the costs of relegation too.

Click to expand...

Would it cover the losses though?

Reduced crowds, Championship wages in League One.

If we're losing money in this League we'd be losing even more if we dropped a division.

 

Mellotron

I've asked for soup

Jul 2, 2008

31,835

Brighton

• Aug 19, 2013

• #8

Tyrone Biggums said:

Sorry, should have prefaced. We're in the Championship and it's the League Cup

Click to expand...

Difficult one. I think I'd take it, because I believe we have the infrastructure and stability to get back into the Championship pretty quickly.

 

Hillian1

( . ) ( . )

Jul 15, 2010

15,364

Struggling for breath at the top of the stairs

• Aug 19, 2013

• #9

Stay up.

 

Tyrone Biggums

Well-known member

Jun 25, 2006

13,498

Geelong, Australia

• Aug 19, 2013

• Thread starter
• #10

Mellotron said:

Difficult one. I think I'd take it, because I believe we have the infrastructure and stability to get back into the Championship pretty quickly.

Click to expand...

I think I'll forever be an eggshells fan.

Knowing what we've gone through and our past I'll always chose the option where our future and stability are more assured.

Even if it means a lack of silverware. Just happy to have the club still alive and kicking.

 

symyjym

Banned

Nov 2, 2009

13,138

Brighton / Hove actually

• Aug 19, 2013

• #11

I think you needed to start this thread on the wigan fans forum.

 

Tyrone Biggums

Well-known member

Jun 25, 2006

13,498

Geelong, Australia

• Aug 19, 2013

• Thread starter
• #12

symyjym said:

I think you needed to start this thread on the wigan fans forum.

Click to expand...

They may repsond differently, but then again they don't have our past.

 

deletebeepbeepbeep

Well-known member

May 12, 2009

20,956

• Aug 19, 2013

• #13

Cup, agree that's what football is about and we'd be talking about it for the next Century. A relegation to the first division wouldn't be all that extraordinary given our history.

 

Hyperion

New member

Nov 1, 2010

5,314

• Aug 19, 2013

• #14

Ask Pompey

 

Seagulltonian

C'mon the Albion!

Oct 2, 2003

2,773

Still Somewhere in Sussex!

• Aug 19, 2013

• #15

Well, as we are out of the League Cup (COC Cup - Or whatever it is called!), I think you need to change it to FA Cup

Cup run very excited to be on one of those! As long as we don't replicate 83, and lose in the final and go down.

I seem to remember not long ago, the excitement in our season was a Johnstone's Paint trophy run, where we lost to Luton in the area final! How times have changed!

 

DavidinSouthampton

Well-known member

NSC Patron

Jan 3, 2012

16,580

• Aug 19, 2013

• #16

deletebeepbeepbeep said:

Cup, agree that's what football is about and we'd be talking about it for the next Century. A relegation to the first division wouldn't be all that extraordinary given our history.

Click to expand...

Given our recent history and what has been achieved over the last three seasons or so, I think relegation would be catastrophic. I agree we would have the infrastructure and so on to bounce back, and I don't mean catastrophic in terms of leading to disaster, but to get to the position where we needed to bounce back that much would be awful.

Having said that, I would still be here.

 

countryman

Well-known member

Jun 28, 2011

1,893

• Aug 19, 2013

• #17

Winning a cup is more important. Cups are remembered for ever. we can get over a relegation and go back up again at some point but it is very rare to win a cup. And who wouldn't want a chance to play in Europe?

 

Joey Jo Jo Jr. Shabadoo

Waxing chumps like candles since ‘75

Oct 4, 2003

11,055

• Aug 19, 2013

• #18

Mustafa said:

Trophy, all day long - that's the point of football isn't it? Would be remembered for the next 50 years or longer

League Cup money would more than cover the costs of relegation too.

Click to expand...

The winners of the league cup get about £100,000. I doubt that would cover the loss in revenue if we were relegated to league 1

 

Joey Jo Jo Jr. Shabadoo

Waxing chumps like candles since ‘75

Oct 4, 2003

11,055

• Aug 19, 2013

• #19

Mustafa said:

True, I had to look that up - Pathetic amount for a national trophy. The TV money is about the same amount, overall the winners get about £500k after that and gates - It's pretty clear why few teams take it seriously.

However - the winner does qualify for the Europa League - which if a club of our size qualified, it would be like hitting the jackpot.

Click to expand...

Although European football would be great I'm not sure that the Europa League would be that lucrative, we certainly have to get to the group stages to have any real money coming in from it. Plus it's a lot more games and as we've seen with other sides they can struggle with a Thursday Sunday schedule, being in League 1 would also see us having to take part in the johnsons paint or whatever it's called. I think it would still prove to be more costly long term than the original euphoria of winning the cup would be worth.

 

SeagullSongs

And it's all gone quiet..

Oct 10, 2011

6,937

Southampton

• Aug 19, 2013

• #20

I would take relegation this year if it meant we would win the FA Cup.

As long as the semi-finals aren't at Wembley though, which f***ing idiot thought that would be a good idea?