Question: If Palace don't make the Play-offs, but we do........................

Superphil

Dismember

Jul 7, 2003

25,431

In a pile of football shirts

• Apr 14, 2013

• #21

We've signed Kanchelskis! said:

He is on loan at Crystal Palace until the 30th June 2013, on the 1st July 2013 he will join Crystal Palace for 350k (what we paid). As he will still be contracted to them even if we make the play-offs and they don't (which won't happen) he won't be able to play for us.

Click to expand...

Straight up question, where does this information come from? I can't recall seeing it anywhere other than on here posted by people who I guess are ITK, but the details all seem so specific, yet surely it's a confidential deal between the clubs, Player and agent.

 

nwgull

Well-known member

Jul 25, 2003

13,861

Manchester

• Apr 14, 2013

• #22

Why would we want Dobbie back? He was mediocre at best when he played for us, and it doesn't look like he's done much better at Palace since January.

 

Stat Brother

Well-known member

NSC Patron

Jul 11, 2003

73,870

West west west Sussex

• Apr 14, 2013

• #23

nwgull said:

Why would we want Dobbie back? He was mediocre at best when he played for us, and it doesn't look like he's done much better at Palace since January.

Click to expand...

Cos Barnes will get sent off v Blackpool and Barker will injure himself on his skateboard. & half a (Barker doesn't have a skateboard!)

 

TheMajor

BHA>CPFC

Sep 27, 2011

3,431

laughing at the size of the JackHunts crowds.

• Apr 14, 2013

• #24

I do hope we tied up the fact that when Palace don't make the play offs they still have to buy him.

No way would he be welcomed back here.

 

Frutos

.

Helpful Moderator

NSC Patron

May 3, 2006

35,634

Northumberland

• Apr 14, 2013

• #25

We've signed Kanchelskis! said:

He is on loan at Crystal Palace until the 30th June 2013, on the 1st July 2013 he will join Crystal Palace for 350k (what we paid). As he will still be contracted to them even if we make the play-offs and they don't (which won't happen) he won't be able to play for us.

Click to expand...

This with blue and white bells on.

 

W

We've signed Kanchelskis!

New member

Feb 12, 2013

100

• Apr 14, 2013

• #26

Superphil said:

Straight up question, where does this information come from? I can't recall seeing it anywhere other than on here posted by people who I guess are ITK, but the details all seem so specific, yet surely it's a confidential deal between the clubs, Player and agent.

Click to expand...

Not really pal, because he'd already been at two clubs this season he couldn't join Palace permanently so had to go on loan. The loan is un till the end of the footballing year, no season - this is because loan deals that result in the player joining permanently have to be til the end of the year not season. The only bit 'ITK' is about the price, but I can assure you it's just covering our losses on him

 

H

HawkTheSeagull

New member

Jan 31, 2012

9,122

Eastbourne

• Apr 14, 2013

• #27

catfish said:

Who cares what he does? He's the worst player to wear an Albion shirt for several years.

Click to expand...

Ashley Barnes ?

(I dont actually mean this but i may as well say it before someone else does, just to ruin their fun)

Oh and Dobbie can stay there for all i care, he hasnt played well there and has wore Palace colours - we dont want him back, that and we now have Leo Ulloa of course, who is a million times better !!!

 

B

blue2

New member

Apr 21, 2010

1,229

• Apr 14, 2013

• #28

hove born&bred said:

....Dobbie?

Click to expand...

I will laugh

 

seagullsovergrimsby

#cpfctinpotclub

Aug 21, 2005

43,691

Crap Town

• Apr 14, 2013

• #29

Superphil said:

Straight up question, where does this information come from? I can't recall seeing it anywhere other than on here posted by people who I guess are ITK, but the details all seem so specific, yet surely it's a confidential deal between the clubs, Player and agent.

Click to expand...

The figure quoted is speculative , all I know is we will get back what we paid Swansea , his wages and bonuses while he was here and a tiny bit on top. The fee when he joins Palarse will be undisclosed (unless one of the Steve's brags about it on BBS)

 

Superphil

Dismember

Jul 7, 2003

25,431

In a pile of football shirts

• Apr 14, 2013

• #30

All made up then, fair enough. .

 

seagullsovergrimsby

#cpfctinpotclub

Aug 21, 2005

43,691

Crap Town

• Apr 14, 2013

• #31

Superphil said:

All made up then, fair enough. .

Click to expand...

Orlandi and Dobbie were both signed from Swansea with undisclosed fees. I think the £350k figure is a random guess from somebody posting on a Swansea message board about the fee for Orlandi.

 

J

jackcgull

Active member

Feb 1, 2008

607

Amersham

• Apr 14, 2013

• #32

i thought you meant dobbie would be the reason for the reversal of fortunes. As Phil says, i don't suppose anyone know the actual details of the deal - but i would be very surprised to see him come back.

 

Braders

Abi Fletchers Gimpboy

Jul 15, 2003

29,224

Brighton, United Kingdom

• Apr 14, 2013

• #33

Titus said:

Why are you even discussing this? He wouldn't make the squad anyway.

Click to expand...

Exactly

 

Mowgli37

Enigmatic Asthmatic

Jan 13, 2013

6,371

Sheffield

• Apr 14, 2013

• #34

He's been tainted by the scum now so I don't think any of us want him back. If he WAS to return he would probably be released or sold in the summer.