Kosh
'The' Yaztromo
Is that Northern speak for throwing down the gauntlet?
Nay, it’s Dane speak lad... it means prepare for a fight to the death for some slight misunderstanding over the dinner seating arrangements
Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊
Game of thrones
- Thread starter matthew
- Start date
Nay, it’s Dane speak lad... it means prepare for a fight to the death for some slight misunderstanding over the dinner seating arrangements
Joey Jo Jo Jr. Shabadoo
Waxing chumps like candles since ‘75
- Oct 4, 2003
- 11,070
I've not watched all of it yet but the first table read through of the new series was interesting. The reactions when they found out about key parts of the series showed who had read the scripts prior to the table read and who hadn't.
As for changing lives I can understand what the cast are getting at, for a lot of them it's the first major hit show they've starred in and it will open lots of doors for their careers. They will also forever be their GOT characters in the same way Star Wars actors have a life long link to their characters.
BadFish
Huge Member
- Oct 19, 2003
- 17,110
Hungry Joe
SINNEN
DumLum
Well-known member
Now that I've watched the whole series, I'm reading through this thread. It looks like no one predicted Ayra would kill the Knight King, which surprises me. I mean, Ayra would sit right at the top of the list of people you wouldn't want to piss off.
I agree with this. But then I also agree with this:
Yes they had to die, but I guess it would have been nice to see some of the white walkers being badass. One main character saving another from the dead, followed by being sliced in half down the middle by a white walker would have been fitting. In the whole battle, the white walkers (save the Might King killing Theon) didn't kill a single person did they?
Disappointed I can't give this two thumbs up.
Braggfan
In the beginning there was nothing, which exploded
- May 12, 2014
- 1,833
I can live with the way the Night king was killed, because I think the rushed th series and if it had been longer I think they would have built his death up more. But killing off the whitewalkers so early on was just bad writing. Its structurally flawed to kill off the main baddies so early because it creates an anti climax. In fact it left a void that they had to try and fill with something big, which came in the form of Daenerys going mental out of nowhere. The story was literally falling apart at the seams by the end. They could easily have rejigged it so that they could have dealt with Kings Landing first and had the battle of Winterfell as the climax. I'm almost certain it would have led to a much more satisfying ending.
Nigella's Cream Pie
Fingerlickin good
They killed plenty - there was a mass funeral the following day
BadFish
Huge Member
- Oct 19, 2003
- 17,110
There was no need to rush any of it. They had a rich and absorbing story woven with interesting threads of plot, lore and theory. They chose to sacrifice all of this for a quick finish.
Why?
BBassic
I changed this.
- Jul 28, 2011
- 12,318
Rumours abound that D&D wanted to get it finished so they could move on to their Star Wars project.
Seem to recall reading somewhere that GoT was meant to be 10 seasons with S8 being all about the White Walkers / Night King, S9 being about the aftermath and what to do about Cersei with S10 being about Daenerys. Her eventual turn to madness would have been developed over the three seasons so it felt like an actual bit of character development.
Question is why the chuff didn't D&D hand the reigns over to someone else so that they could Star Wars and GoT stood a chance of having a well written, well paced and satisfying conclusion.
They were killed by the dead, not by the white walkers. Did a white walker kill anyone other than Theon?
blue-shifted
Banned
They killed others in earlier series, I was talking about the main battle, S8,E3.
There were thousands of dead, and they killed thousands of men. But the white walkers themselves did **** all.
That would have been better.
Towards the end of the battle with the dead, Brienne of Tarth should have been losing a battle against the mounting numbers of dead, for Jamie to step in and save her at the last minute. Then, as he reached out to her hand to lift her back up, he should have been sliced in half (vertically, from the shoulder) by a white walker. Brienne would have then killed the walker.
The camera could have shown that Ayra saw this, so then when we saw Jamie head south, we'd have know who it really was. Ayra could have got Cersei all hot and excitedly ready for a good shag, before sticking the knife in and taking his face off.
Normal Rob
Well-known member
Maybe i'm wrong on this, but i kind of viewed the white walkers as generals marshalling the troops? They didn't need to get their hands dirty (metaphorically speaking)
Yeah maybe that's fair. But when we saw them fighting Gilly and her family some series back, weren't the white walkers doing the fighting back then? And in the battle, we didn't actually see them being generals did we? The knight king flew about on his dragon, but then all the white walkers were just standing there at the end to watch their boss get owned.
Normal Rob
Well-known member
yes, but seeming as (up to that final point when Arya jumps out) the dead were well on top, they were not expecting what happened to take place. Once it did, they all fell to pieces. There was plenty wrong with the final series for sure, but for me that's not one of the issues.