Should piss-taking opposing supporters be banned from the Big Board

Bozza · Oct 19, 2011

NSC has long been far more liberal in the acceptance of opposing fans.

If you're big enough to give it out, you need to be big enough to take it.

Many opposing fans who make it to NSC offer well considered input to many of the discussions here. There are some, however, who do not and just seek to take the piss again and again and again.

Should this latter group be kicked off NSC's Big Board and only allowed to post in a new 'Away End'. The Away End would be accessible to all regular members meaning each NSCer could decide whether to ignore the sub-forum completely, have a read every now and again or engage with the away fans who post there.

What happens now

Opposing fan joins NSC - free to post anywhere
Opposing fan pisstakes a bit - free to post anywhere
Opposing fans pisstakes a lot - gets a warning
Opposing fan goes too far - banned

Proposal

Opposing fan joins NSC - free to post anywhere
Opposing fan pisstakes a bit - gets a warning
Opposing fans pisstakes a lot - moved to 'away end'
Opposing fan goes too far - banned

This poll will be open for a week. Votes from opposing fans will be discounted.

Bozza · Oct 19, 2011

And, regardless of the above, opposing fans who go too far with language, spamming and homophobia etc will still be banned completely from the site.

The Large One · Oct 19, 2011

'Ribbing' is one thing, that comes under 'banter'. We're talking about persistent piss-takers.

Your thread title is misleading.

So there.

Bozza · Oct 19, 2011

The Large One said:
'Ribbing' is one thing, that comes under 'banter'. We're talking about persistent piss-takers.

Your thread title is misleading.

So there.

Answer the non-misleading poll question whilst I rename the thread then.

Tony Meolas Loan Spell · Oct 19, 2011

Sticky please.

And vote YES

hans kraay fan club · Oct 19, 2011

Banned, NO - not simply for being away fans, nor for a bit of ribbing. If they're abusive then yes of course.

Tony Meolas Loan Spell · Oct 19, 2011

hans kraay fan club said:
Banned, NO - not simply for being away fans, nor for a bit of ribbing. If they're abusive then yes of course.

Or ban for posting the SAME old dribble like saintswilltopplebrighton does for example. At the very least MOVE to an away fans section.

There are some good away fans, even some Palace, let them STAY on the main board.

Vegas Seagull · Oct 19, 2011

NSC is THE most popular site via Tapatalk out of 177 others Inc ManCity, Celtic, Man U etc... Ban a few more individuals as reqd, but it ain't broke DON'T....

hans kraay fan club · Oct 19, 2011

Vegas Seagull said:
NSC is THE most popular site via Tapatalk out of 177 others Inc ManCity, Celtic, Man U etc... Ban a few more individuals as reqd, but it ain't broke DON'T....

Entirely this.

tubaman · Oct 19, 2011

Not all away fans should be banned. Only the attention seeking idiots

middletoenail · Oct 19, 2011

I like well constructed piss takes from the away fans, we may not have the best team in the league but we have the best message board. In short, keep it the way it is!

[MENTION=6886]Bozza[/MENTION] How would you moderate this should it change, would it be a case of moving a thread individually into a 'away fans' section if it were created in the Big Board? Surely this would be tiresome?

mcshane in the 79th · Oct 19, 2011

It's the idiot brighton fans that are pissing me off more than away fans!. The ones that post wind up thread after wind up thread being delibrately negative.

I would prefer away fans to be given a trial on the Big Board then if they turn out to be eejits, then limit them to an Away only board. Would be a shame to lose a lot of the quality away fans we have on here from Plymouth, Southampton, Charlton and even Palace by not allowing them to post on the Big Board

cjd · Oct 19, 2011

Unfortunately, (and I do mean that) they should be consigned to a new away end....or banned.

Having read and been part of this board for some considerable time, the number of away fans utterly taking the piss has seriously diminished the enjoyment of this forum.

When a Palace fan consistently insults and abuses this board with a final "f*** off and die" to an Albion poster is tolerated by the moderators is in my opinion a serious mis-judgement by the mods.

You remind people that there is always the 'Report' facility. Well, I did use this facility following the above remark by the Palace supporter. The result was a PM from one moderator refusing to ban him and suggesting if WE stopped posting, so would the Palace supporter. Another moderator also backed this up by saying he felt a 'warning' was more than adequate. In my opinion....both were poor judgements.

If this forum is to be enjoyed by Brighton supporters, then such leniency will not only discourage new posters, but also encourage the more offensive posts.

Banter is one thing....down right offensive and vicious posting....particularly from away supporters is another.

The Large One · Oct 19, 2011

Bozza said:
Answer the non-misleading poll question whilst I rename the thread then.

I have, but I can't tell you what I voted because it's hidden.

Acker79 · Oct 19, 2011

Aren't persistent piss takers banned regardless of who they support? Isn't giving them their own forum inviting the sort of posters you normally ban?

The Large One · Oct 19, 2011

cjd said:
Unfortunately, (and I do mean that) they should be consigned to a new away end....or banned.

Having read and been part of this board for some considerable time, the number of away fans utterly taking the piss has seriously diminished the enjoyment of this forum.

When a Palace fan consistently insults and abuses this board with a final "f*** off and die" to an Albion poster is tolerated by the moderators is in my opinion a serious mis-judgement by the mods.

You remind people that there is always the 'Report' facility. Well, I did use this facility following the above remark by the Palace supporter. The result was a PM from one moderator refusing to ban him and suggesting if WE stopped posting, so would the Palace supporter. Another moderator also backed this up by saying he felt a 'warning' was more than adequate. In my opinion....both were poor judgements.

If this forum is to be enjoyed by Brighton supporters, then such leniency will not only discourage new posters, but also encourage the more offensive posts.

Banter is one thing....down right offensive and viscious posting....particularly from away supporters is another.

For the most part - this.

Tony Meolas Loan Spell · Oct 19, 2011

I will say it. Too f***ing namby pamby. A bit of zero tolerance is needed frankly.

As my MD would say these new wind up thread starters need a FIFO massage.

Fit In or f*** Off

Gus is god · Oct 19, 2011

Can you vote on a poll on tapatalk?

If not my answer is No. Reason is some are top. Others are annoying but that's life.

What's more annoying is posts like "were f***ing shit" etc.... And.constant putting the club down when they have gone through hoops for us.

seagulls

Titanic · Oct 19, 2011

mcshane in the 79th said:
It's the idiot brighton fans that are pissing me off more than away fans!. The ones that post wind up thread after wind up thread being delibrately negative.

I would prefer away fans to be given a trial on the Big Board then if they turn out to be eejits, then limit them to an Away only board. Would be a shame to lose a lot of the quality away fans we have on here from Plymouth, Southampton, Charlton and even Palace by not allowing them to post on the Big Board

Spot on.

And we should have a similar category of Brighton fans who can only post in the 'Childish Drivel' forum.

pasty · Oct 19, 2011

I vote no. I don't take an awful lot of notice of those sort of threads to be honest, and rarely reply to them. However, if I did and they were on a sub-forum I doubt I'd even see them.

Leave it be - I'm a great believer in "if you don't like it, don't read it"

Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊

Should piss-taking opposing supporters be banned from the Big Board

Should piss-taking opposing fans be kicked off the Big Board?

Yes - consign them to a new 'away end'

No - let them stay here, we need to man up a bit

You can change this

You can change this

Who's Next?

You can change this

Slut Faced Whores

The voice of reason.

Slut Faced Whores

New member

The voice of reason.

Member

Well-known member

New member

Well-known member

Who's Next?

Well-known member

Who's Next?

Slut Faced Whores

Banned

Super Moderator

A different kind of pasty

Share this page