Which is your favourite Amex PIE?

Man of Harveys

Well-known member

Jul 9, 2003

18,738

Brighton, UK

• Aug 28, 2011

• #1

Apologies if this has been done before (it may well have been) but I thought the thread about the chicken and ham pie suggested a poll: simply, which is your favourite of the extraordinary pies our fine new home offers up? Let's face it, they're all superb, although not being weird I've yet to try the veggie one. Cheers.

 

Last edited: Aug 28, 2011

nomoremithras4me

Active member

Apr 7, 2011

2,348

• Aug 28, 2011

• #2

Steak & ale for me, f@@king hot though, nearly took the skin off the roof of my mouth yesterday

 

Hungry Joe

SINNEN

Oct 22, 2004

7,636

Heading for shore

• Aug 28, 2011

• #3

Haven't treid the veggie yet but out of the meaties the steak and ale just pips the chicken.....just.

 

Easy 10

Brain dead MUG SHEEP

Jul 5, 2003

61,764

Location Location

• Aug 28, 2011

• #4

nomoremithras4me said:

Steak & ale for me, f@@king hot though, nearly took the skin off the roof of my mouth yesterday

Click to expand...

Same.

I actually had to scoop a half-chewed lump of steak out of my gob yesterday as it was like a hot coal in there. EYEWATERING.

 

Giraffe

VERY part time moderator

Helpful Moderator

NSC Patron

Aug 8, 2005

26,549

• Aug 28, 2011

• #5

Only had one so can't vote but my mate says chicken is the best.

 

pasty

A different kind of pasty

Jul 5, 2003

30,283

West, West, West Sussex

• Aug 28, 2011

• #6

Had my first S&A yesterday. Chicken and ham wins.

 

Man of Harveys

Well-known member

Jul 9, 2003

18,738

Brighton, UK

• Aug 28, 2011

• Thread starter
• #7

Easy 10 said:

Same.

I actually had to scoop a half-chewed lump of steak out of my gob yesterday as it was like a hot coal in there. EYEWATERING.

Click to expand...

I found that a) turning them upside down in their box and b) waiting about 10 minutes to eat them brought the temperature down. But that took a superhuman patience that I never knew I had in me.

 

The Large One

Who's Next?

Jul 7, 2003

52,343

97.2FM

• Aug 28, 2011

• #8

They're all great, but seeing as one S&A pie I had was only 8/10 (rather than the usual 10/10), I've gone for C&H - for consistency's sake, and because it just pips the veggie one.

 

Last edited: Aug 28, 2011

7:18

Brighton & Hove Albion

Aug 6, 2006

8,462

Brighton, England

• Aug 28, 2011

• #9

Chicken and Ham every time!

 

bennibenj

Well-known member

Mar 6, 2011

2,063

Sompting

• Aug 28, 2011

• #10

Steak and Ale bang on

 

Wilko

LUZZING chairs about

Sep 19, 2003

9,923

BN1

• Aug 28, 2011

• #11

Any 1901ers had the stilton one yet?

 

S

SirElliotBennett

New member

May 5, 2010

1,741

West Stand Lower

• Aug 28, 2011

• #12

Still haven't had one yet.
Must try one next game.

 

Man of Harveys

Well-known member

Jul 9, 2003

18,738

Brighton, UK

• Aug 28, 2011

• Thread starter
• #13

And chicken and ham edges ahead...interesting (well...sort of).

 

Woodchip

It's all about the bikes

Aug 28, 2004

14,460

Shaky Town, NZ

• Aug 28, 2011

• #14

Can't wait for the Chicken Balti to go on trial

 

Sussex

MDAL

Apr 14, 2011

312

• Aug 28, 2011

• #15

Chicken & Ham but holding out for a Balti!

 

BUTTERBALL

East Stand Brighton Boyz

Jul 31, 2003

10,255

location location

• Aug 28, 2011

• #16

Was steak and ale until i tried the chicken and ham.

 

Cowfold Seagull

Fan of the 17 bus

Apr 22, 2009

21,631

Cowfold

• Aug 28, 2011

• #17

Steak and ale for me, beats the steak and gristle offering at Withdean hands down.

lnteresting though, on paper l would have preferred the chicken and ham l think, but in reality, l found it rather too salty for my taste.

 

Everest

Me

Jul 5, 2003

20,741

Southwick

• Aug 28, 2011

• #18

Chicken/ham.
Yesterday's was not up to the usual standard though.
Yes, it was hot, but there was just something about it that wasn't right.

 

Tom Hark Preston Park

Will Post For Cash

Jul 6, 2003

70,186

• Aug 28, 2011

• #19

Chicken/Ham. Lots of lovely tasty stuff in there.

 

Beach Hut

Brighton Bhuna Boy

Jul 5, 2003

71,969

Living In a Box

• Aug 28, 2011

• #20

Still to buy a pie so cannot comment however bought a pint of Harveys at half-time yesterday for the first time and it was very flat to say the least.