Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊

Why is it illegal to say Sieg Heil in Germany?



Biscuit

Native Creative
Jul 8, 2003
22,215
Brighton
When all it actually means is "Hail [to] Victory"....If you are caught saying this in Germany for any reason other than that of art, teaching or science purposes you can get a 3 years in the nick!

I'm sure it's about its connotations with the Nazi party, but is it not worth claiming it back? The Swastika stood for well being before the Nazi's claimed it, can't this be claimed back to? In the same way Englanders have claimed back the cross of St George from the fascists? People in Germany get arrested for showing this symbol anywhere, even if its in an antifascist demonstration!


--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
A controversy was stirred by the decision of several police departments to begin inquiries against anti-fascists.[41] In late 2005 police raided the offices of the punklabel and mailorder "Nix Gut Records" and confiscated merchandise depicting crossed-out swastikas and fists smashing swastikas.[42] In 2006 the Stade police department started an inquiry against anti-fascist youths using a placard, depicting a person dumping a swastika into a trashcan. The placard was displayed in opposition to the campaign of right-wing nationalist parties for local elections.[43]

On Friday, March 17, 2006 member of the Bundestag Claudia Roth reported herself to the German police for displaying a crossed-out swastika on multiple demonstrations against Neo-Nazis, and subsequently got the Bundestag to suspend her immunity from prosecution. She intends to show the absurdity of charging anti-fascists with using fascist symbols: "We don't need prosecution of non-violent young people engaging against right-wing extremism."[42]
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------


Looked it up on wiki and we get a footnote.. ""The Sun newspaper reported that Millwall F.C. sung 'Sieg Heil', during a Millwall v Brighton Match at The New Den. Millwall denied this, and said they were mocking Brighton's chant of "Seagulls"."

Now please no racist rubbish or personal attacks, I think this is actually quite an interesting debate!
 






Shizuoka Dolphin

NSC M0DERATOR
Jul 8, 2003
6,987
N/A
In the majority of countries around the world the swastika still DOES have a good meaning.

The reasons for Sieg Heil being illegal are obvious and there's no reason to make any attempt to claim it back.
 


Ridiculous!

Would that phrase be useful in another context for Germans? No, it's as unique to nazi culture as would be 'kill Catholics' might be in English.

What might be a reasonable question though, is....what if a foreigner, particularly an English person - said that phrase in Germany? Would they be imprisoned for 3 years?
One might say it in jest or sarcasm, for instance, at an overbearing boss or something - but for a German to say it, it wouldn't be a normal sarcastic response to anything. In irony, it would also be outrageously off the mark.

NMH say; entspannen , ausführen nicht stehen es.
 
Last edited:






Bevendean Hillbilly

New member
Sep 4, 2006
12,805
Nestling in green nowhere
Whilst we are at it, what is wrong with other Nazi slogans, I would love "Arbeit Macht Frei" above my desk, of "Ein Volk, Ein Reich Ein Fuhrer" or hey, lets go hog wild, lets all sing the "Horst Wessel Song" every morning on our commute to work.

Hitler, great bloke. voted for him last time, would vote for him again. At least he got the trains running on time.

Seig Heil.
 


Shizuoka Dolphin

NSC M0DERATOR
Jul 8, 2003
6,987
N/A
On a semi-related theme, was at the football on Saturday and saw this delightful flag in amongst the visiting fans:

nazicross.jpg


???
 


It's like the "Roman salute" in Italy. Its use by neo-fascist ultras at football matches is in no way a "reclaiming back" of a mis-used symbol of the past. It's a reassertion of fascism - an evil political movement that led to the deaths of millions (including many Italian citizens).

One of the first things the Italian democracy did when it was restored in 1946 was to ban the symbols of fascism as part of a difficult reconstruction programme. The Germans did the same.

The people who want to reverse this have no decent motives.
 








Man of Harveys

Well-known member
Jul 9, 2003
18,734
Brighton, UK
Are you f***ing mad? "Reclaiming" "sieg heil"? :nono: :nono: WTF?
 






Bevendean Hillbilly

New member
Sep 4, 2006
12,805
Nestling in green nowhere
Buzzer said:
Sorry, only read the 1st post and didn't get any further. Do you think this is a wind up thread?

I hope so mate.
 






Buzzer

Languidly Clinical
Oct 1, 2006
26,121
Bevendean Hillbilly said:

Ironically, the attempt to recruit British people into the foreign divisions of the SS was a singular failure, Lord Haw-Haw apart. They scoured the POW camps and interviewed British officers who were sympathetic to the aims but even then got a firm two-fingers up.

I'd like to think that it's all down to British fair play. We may moan like a Daily Mail obsessed Colonel form Tunbridge Wells but when push comes to shove we just find extremist politics just too unpalatable to stomach.

Bollocks to all revisionists and compulsory reading of Primo Levi for all holocaust deniers.
 


Man of Harveys

Well-known member
Jul 9, 2003
18,734
Brighton, UK
Buzzer said:
I'd like to think that it's all down to British fair play. We may moan like a Daily Mail obsessed Colonel form Tunbridge Wells but when push comes to shove we just find extremist politics just too unpalatable to stomach.
What a jolly splendid load of rather smug and complacent tosh and poppycock what what old bean - for starters, the Daily Mail doted on Hitler throughout the 1930s and actively supported him right up to the point where war broke out, campaiging for Nazi Germany to have its pre-1918 colonies restored. Rothermere (the publisher then whose family publishes the rag still) met with Hitler a number of times - and was vocally pro Chamberlain's appeasement of him - that's when they weren't openly campaigning on behalf of the homegrown far right, the Daily Mail memorably opining "Hurrah for the blackshirts!".

Rothermere and friend
BUrother2.jpg


Of course, then as now, the Daily Mail ranted and raved against immigrants, at that time many of whom were Jews fleeing the growing persecution in the rest of Europe. Plus ca change.
 


Bevendean Hillbilly

New member
Sep 4, 2006
12,805
Nestling in green nowhere
Buzzer said:
Ironically, the attempt to recruit British people into the foreign divisions of the SS was a singular failure, Lord Haw-Haw apart. They scoured the POW camps and interviewed British officers who were sympathetic to the aims but even then got a firm two-fingers up.

I'd like to think that it's all down to British fair play. We may moan like a Daily Mail obsessed Colonel form Tunbridge Wells but when push comes to shove we just find extremist politics just too unpalatable to stomach.

Bollocks to all revisionists and compulsory reading of Primo Levi for all holocaust deniers.

The "Legion of St. George" (originally called "The British Legion" until someone pointed out that in the UK that means a smoky room full of old men drinking Mild) was a reality attracting a right old hotch potch of Australians,New Zealanders, Irish and a few british fascists, but I think it never got above about 40 members.

One or two reports say that they did fight against the Russians at the end of the war, but others say they were never operational

I saw a documentary about it some time back and the "quality" of the men who joined was poor, and it seems to me they were often petty criminals and chancers, one even said that he only joined because British insignia on the SS uniform guaranteed a shag!

When you look at the amount of French, Dutch, Danes and especially Belgians who were happy to join the SS as compared to British POW's it is quite remarkable.

Strangely, after the war, men who joined the Legion did not face charges for treason, and by and large slipped quietly back into civillian life
 


Wozza

Shite Supporter
Jul 6, 2003
23,613
Online
Buzzer said:
Sorry, only read the 1st post and didn't get any further. Do you think this is a wind up thread?

If it is, the joke element is heavily disguised.
 




Buzzer

Languidly Clinical
Oct 1, 2006
26,121
Man of Harveys said:
What a jolly splendid load of rather smug and complacent tosh and poppycock what what old bean - for starters, the Daily Mail doted on Hitler throughout the 1930s and actively supported him right up to the point where war broke out, campaiging for Nazi Germany to have its pre-1918 colonies restored. Rothermere (the publisher then whose family publishes the rag still) met with Hitler a number of times - and was vocally pro Chamberlain's appeasement of him - that's when they weren't openly campaigning on behalf of the homegrown far right, the Daily Mail memorably opining "Hurrah for the blackshirts!".

Rothermere and friend
BUrother2.jpg


Of course, then as now, the Daily Mail ranted and raved against immigrants, at that time many of whom were Jews fleeing the growing persecution in the rest of Europe. Plus ca change.

Hang on. There's several different issues here. A newspaper's support for a dictator isn't necessarily reflective of the population and because a newspaper magnate admires Hitler ergo the British at large do is just too many extrapolations.

As for campaigning for Danzig and Alsace-Lorraine et al to be returned to Germany, I don't actually see a problem with that. The Germans were arse-f***ed by the treaties of Locarno and Versailles and this led directly to the mistrust and ill-feeling in pre-Nazi Germany. Once again, the British carve up a country only for troubles further down the line. Rhodesia, Balkans, Lebanon, Iraq, Hong Kong, Yemen etc etc etc.

The extremists have never gained anything more than silly and irrelevant victories in the UK and each victory has been overturned shortly after. Don't forget that the battle of Brick Lane was in the 30s - albeit by working class people and not typical Daily Mail readers.

I'll stand by that statement that we British don't like extremist politics. Sure - you'll find individuals who do but none that have had sustained success at the ballot box.
 


Chesney Christ

New member
Sep 3, 2003
4,301
Location, Location
Biskuit von Kekse said:
When all it actually means is "Hail [to] Victory"....If you are caught saying this in Germany for any reason other than that of art, teaching or science purposes you can get a 3 years in the nick!


Because its POLITICAL CORRECTNESS GONE MAD. No doubt the PC Brigade will all be on here in a minute because you aren't allowed to think racist thoughts in this PC BLair gone mad country anymore if you're in the silent majority :angry:
 


Albion and Premier League latest from Sky Sports


Top
Link Here