I've made a list of pro's and cons between the 2 games, as I have bought both games pretty much year on year - might help some people come to a decision
Fifa:
Pros:
Ingame presentation is great as its very true to life in terms of presentation packages (if you like the Premier League, or the...
they won't put much effort into updating the game for the older systems
to be fair, they don't put much resource into anything other than FUT anyway as they can suck more money out of people that way