Really? Looking for a foul, throwing his arms in the air then trudging back while the opposition pass the ball around him doesn't constitute 'tracking back' in my opinion (though he did get stuck in by a corner flag once I seem to remember). But I'm glad you found enjoyment watching him.
What Barnes goals? I'm sorry but 5 goals (including 2 penalties) doesn't amount to that much of a loss. I'm more concerned about losing Ashley's other skills like holding the ball up while support arrived (average) or his tracking back (poor) I can't see how Albion lost that much really, OG must...