I totally disagree with that, but each to their own. The analysis is generally really shallow and poor.
But the reasons I assumed they wouldn't is that there are so many other ways to consume highlights of games without having to sit through an hour of Shearer and Murphy talking bollocks.
I tend to watch the highlights on Sky straight after the games or watch Goals on Sunday if I'm around and want some actual analysis. I'd be interested to know what percentage of MOTD viewers are an older vs younger crowd to be honest.