To be honest, his relegation record is not why I am saying he would be the wrong choice. His relegation record specifically relates to keeping teams in the top flight. I cannot recall him having been relegated with a team outside of the top flight. However, my reservation is that I feel he is...
Warnock has been a good manager, but so too for that matter have George Graham, Terry Venables and Ron Atkinson, but I doubt anyone would be suggesting them for a managerial position these days. The last success Warnock had was in getting QPR promoted 3 jobs ago, but he would have got them...