I would never vote for Peter Taylor (Palace variety). He inherited a team, took no interest in living local, got us promoted and shat on Dick Knight at the promotion party by saying he was "off".
Archie Macauley purely for the best show of attacking football you were ever likely to see in season 64/5. Fact that we had an England centre forward who had scored around 200 goals in the first division might have helped but it was unforgettable.