To be fair, you're both right and I actually think Naylor is a good local journo. I'm also pleased he's not an Albion fan as he gives a good level of objectivity. On the subject of transfers though, he is behind the game. There's a reason for that though - as a journalist in a local rag he print...
Well it's easy to be always right when you don't make any predictions. Every one of his stories have been when he's been given the story a few hours before the general public