Andrews was good at Leicester too.
I don't think Andrews is a terrible player (seemingly contrary to the boo boys opinion of him), but I agree with you because I think he'll be after unjustifiable wages.
Assuming Garcia wants to play his best team, what with football being a results business and his job being to pick a team most likely to win, I'd have thought they probably assessed his fitness and decided that despite Stephens deciding he felt fine, his fitness assessment suggested otherwise...