I don't think I ever said that you personally were. No need to get all shouty.
II'm pretty sure that your opinion is no more important than anyone else's.. I see a game and individual performances differently to a mate I go to games with., that's what makes football interesting, we all have...
This is a problem on NSC. Too many posters are willing to slag off a player on the word of the radio commentary. You only have to look at any match day thread, where no one can actually see what's going on but still feel qualified to pick a players performance apart.