Quite fair.
I think the biggest compliment any of us can (and should pay GP,), is that he changed the playing style completely of a PL club, which is not an easy thing to do. Despite the woeful home form he did a good job. (I also didn’t mind Hughton and he gave the club PL foundations)...
Dreadful.
When he last played he was overweight and movement wise had no idea (or perhaps no inclination of how to move).
He can finish, but I think the championship will be too tough for him. Can’t head the ball (I think that was his own admission early on, and aspires to join Man Utd)...