There were a few 80/90's attempts at Superhero films. I remember seeing a really bad Captain America film that had Ned Beatty as the bad guy but can't remember who played Cap'n.
Here is the trailer, they did the best they could with a poor budget...
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Bo8DcSJqp8I
I had a think about rules. I'm not sure rules work because most people know a bad film when they see it. Ratings don't count much as if you take TV, we all know X Factor is bad but it gets terrific ratings. Or just for knowing summat is bad, we all know Roadhouse is a shocking film, falling into...