This is a highly accurate summary of the exchange. I'm just of the view that you're profoundly wrong about Stockdale's distribution, which I think is one of superb, terrific and great. I don't have any empirical evidence to support any of these claims, it's just my interpretation.
Great comments here, especially on Stockdale and Bruno. I'd go along with most of your scores too, although Greer only warrants a 6 for me, whereas Ince's performance was a 9, worthy of a joint MotM with Tex. I thought Best looked excellent when he came on too, worthy of an 8.