In Albion's case, it would possibly be between Murray and Ward as both played in three divisions for the team. Someone like Tommy Cook would have been limited due to us playing most of that time in the same division.
Ah, Bobby Z would be a consideration too.
You can do it by going to the Seagulls Programmes Site and putting it together from start of season editions which show the previous end of season statto page with individual match scorers. You will have to cobble together the 1975/76 one from individual editions though.
I would do it, but I've...