If we play 2 up front my choice would be Barnes. CMS can't shoot and I think Hoskins is actually made out of balsa wood. I think we're all going to fall into the same trap regarding CMS. It's going to be like when Hoskins was injured and we were all convinced he'd be amazing when he came back...
So he's spent the majority of his career playing for the greatest manager ever, and the rest of it playing for his successor. Can't be too bad an idea can it? I would very much imagine this fits our cost cutting plans also, I'd expect loans from Man Utd and Everton.