Search results

Thanks - didn't see there was a separate thread.

Have they formally questioned it?

Possibly. Although they are standing full on to the image - and therefore their legs are an inverted V. JPVH is standing much more at a sideways stance, so a straighter leg. All-in-all though - it does go to show how difficult it must actually be to make these decisions in a relatively short...

Who knows indeed. The point I was making is that the red line is not in line with JPVH's ankle - which is nearer the ground than his calf. Yes - Mancini's upper body has been 'tracked down' - but JPVH's calf hasn't. If you track down his calf (which will logically be where his ankle is, given...

Haven't you taken the red line from JPVH's calf in the air. Presumably you should be drawing a yellow line down to the ground like you have done with Mancini. Or at least work out where JPVH's foot is likely to be?

Not just his armpit - most of his upper body. Still - look at them all unmarked.....

All goals go to VAR whether called offside or not. He didn't raise his flag till after the ball went in.

It's a bit more than that though. At 2-0 down we were just beginning to look the stronger team, and could maybe have kept it at that or got back to 2-1. The third goal was such a sucker-punch that the the fourth followed on from it.

Indeed. We can discuss the offside all night long - but what were we doing leaving them unmarked. Even if he hadn't reached the ball, there was another guy behind him, who would probably also have scored.

https://www.tntsports.co.uk/football/europa-league/2023-2024/roma-v-brighton-uefa-europa-league-highlights-as-romelu-lukaku-helps-consign-seagulls-to-big-loss_vid2099337/video.shtml 23 seconds on

Just leaving the foot of the guy on the right hand side of the semi-circle. The one who looks as though he is semaphoring.

I think we'll probably have to accept the first one. Even my home-made snip and sketch rule looks as though it was onside.