Despite all of the issues highlighted, I will still remember him for that majestic rise in the box to collect a Liverpool corner at the end of the game to record our first win at Anfield for a long while. Let's not forget the good bits.
In reality he was only 'dropped' once. In the cup game he was the 'cup keeper' - he hadn't 'won back' his first-team place to be dropped again. It's his inability to seemingly understand that which has caused the problems I think.