McCarthy is a talented actress. She doesn't conform to the Hollywood expectancy.
She's typecasted. Don't watch the films she appears in, but don't criticise her look. She's doing well for herself. She's got a career and earnings most people would love.
She's not a Lopez or Diaz, but I think...
She specialises in chick flicks and plays a loud and annoying character. I'm not surprised you are not sold on her.
However, if she was a pin up, this thread wouldn't exist. There are plenty of males that do not match up to Diaz or Lopez.