Whilst I can agree he didn't set the world on fire at Leverkusen, and that tactically he doesn't appear to be all that astute - I can't agree that "we do have good players".
Just look at the players that we've sold/moved on and where they're currently playing and compare them to the players...
I'm inclined to say IN as I still feel he doesn't have a lot of quality to work with, compared to the last few seasons, and I believe every manager deserves at least some time to get things working. I'd like to see what he could do if we actually bought some quality in January. Changing...