Having re-read this and the original question, it turns out it is absolutely clear which specific question you were asking. I apologise for my insolence.
The answer is Vicente.
Mitoma. Because Mitoma is in his prime and playing in the Premier League.
Vicente was well past his best but playing in the Championship, and was head and shoulders above everybody else in the division.
Prime Vicente was better than prime Mitoma. But prime Vicente didn't play for us.
So I...